Catalogue
Best American football games
The best American football games by critic score, from 44 in the catalogue. Madden NFL 17 leads at 8.3/10; ranked games have 20+ critic reviews.
Top 10 American football games
| # | Game | Year | Score | Critic reviews |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Madden NFL 17 | 2016 | 8.3 | 59 |
| 2 | EA Sports College Football 26 | 2025 | 8.3 | 40 |
| 3 | Madden NFL 18 | 2017 | 8.2 | 61 |
| 4 | Madden NFL 16 | 2015 | 8.2 | 54 |
| 5 | Madden NFL 15 | 2014 | 8.1 | 50 |
| 6 | EA Sports College Football 25 | 2024 | 8.1 | 41 |
| 7 | Madden NFL 19 | 2018 | 8.0 | 56 |
| 8 | EA Sports College Football 27 | 2026 | 7.7 | 28 |
| 9 | Madden NFL 26 | 2025 | 7.7 | 44 |
| 10 | Madden NFL 20 | 2019 | 7.4 | 47 |
All American football games by score
Filter American football games by platform, year and score
Missing a game? Add it
RB
8.7Retro BowlMN1
8.3Madden NFL 17ESC
8.3EA Sports College Football 26MN1
8.2Madden NFL 18MN1
8.2Madden NFL 16MN1
8.1Madden NFL 15ESC
8.1EA Sports College Football 25MN1
8.0Madden NFL 19ESC
7.7EA Sports College Football 27MN2
7.7Madden NFL 26CL
7.6Chaos LeagueBB
7.4Blood BowlMN2
7.4Madden NFL 20MN2
7.1Madden NFL 25BB2
7.0Blood Bowl 2MN2
7.0Madden NFL 25MN2
6.8Madden NFL 23MN2
6.8Madden NFL 22MFL
6.7Mutant Football LeagueMN2
6.5Madden NFL 24MN2
6.4Madden NFL 21JMF
9.0John Madden Football '92FPS
9.0Front Page Sports FootballJMF
9.0John Madden FootballTSF
8.8TV Sports: FootballJMF
8.7Joe Montana FootballMN2
8.6Madden NFL 2003BSF
8.5Brutal Sports FootballJMF
8.5John Madden FootballGCF
8.5GFL Championship FootballG
8.5Gridiron!MN2
8.4Madden NFL 2004MDP
8.0Mike Ditka Power FootballC
7.5CyberballTB
7.2Tecmo BowlUR9
7.0Unnecessary Roughness '95P
7.0Pigskin4I
6.94th & InchesGF
6.9Great FootballMN0
5.0Madden NFL 06JMF
4.5John Madden FootballMN9
Madden NFL 98QHFQuick Hit FootballFPSFront Page Sports Football Pro '96
8.7Retro BowlMN1
8.3Madden NFL 17ESC
8.3EA Sports College Football 26MN1
8.2Madden NFL 18MN1
8.2Madden NFL 16MN1
8.1Madden NFL 15ESC
8.1EA Sports College Football 25MN1
8.0Madden NFL 19ESC
7.7EA Sports College Football 27MN2
7.7Madden NFL 26CL
7.6Chaos LeagueBB
7.4Blood BowlMN2
7.4Madden NFL 20MN2
7.1Madden NFL 25BB2
7.0Blood Bowl 2MN2
7.0Madden NFL 25MN2
6.8Madden NFL 23MN2
6.8Madden NFL 22MFL
6.7Mutant Football LeagueMN2
6.5Madden NFL 24MN2
6.4Madden NFL 21JMF
9.0John Madden Football '92FPS
9.0Front Page Sports FootballJMF
9.0John Madden FootballTSF
8.8TV Sports: FootballJMF
8.7Joe Montana FootballMN2
8.6Madden NFL 2003BSF
8.5Brutal Sports FootballJMF
8.5John Madden FootballGCF
8.5GFL Championship FootballG
8.5Gridiron!MN2
8.4Madden NFL 2004MDP
8.0Mike Ditka Power FootballC
7.5CyberballTB
7.2Tecmo BowlUR9
7.0Unnecessary Roughness '95P
7.0Pigskin4I
6.94th & InchesGF
6.9Great FootballMN0
5.0Madden NFL 06JMF
4.5John Madden FootballMN9
Madden NFL 98QHFQuick Hit FootballFPSFront Page Sports Football Pro '96