720 Pokémon and a well-liked story, weighed down by repetitive dungeons
Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.
The best and worst of it, side by side
The strongest praise came from Japan. Famitsu gave it 36 out of 40, with all four of its reviewers scoring it a 9. Destructoid called it a "solid entry" and liked its "tons of customization options" and its "huge roster" of allies and moves.
The sharpest criticism came from Nintendo Life. Mitch Vogel called the game "tedious" and said repetition shows up in nearly every part of it, enough that it can feel like a chore. Game Informer landed in between: better than earlier entries in the series, but still held back by simple combat and repetitive play.
Across 36 counted reviews, the aggregate settled at 69/100, which is mixed or average. Few critics called it bad. Many called it samey.
Every Pokémon of its day is here
The roster is the clearest win. The game includes all 720 Pokémon released at the time, and reviewers singled that out as a highlight. You play as one of 20 Pokémon: the 18 starters from all six main-series generations, plus Pikachu and Riolu. Your partner comes from the remaining 19.
That choice matters because the partner stays with you through every dungeon. With 20 options for your hero and 19 for your partner, there are a lot of pairings to try, which fits the customization Destructoid praised.
The setup follows the series formula. A human wakes up as a Pokémon in a world with no humans, then travels through dungeons, takes on missions and fights enemies while a larger crisis threatens that world.
A story critics liked more than usual
Story is where this entry pulled ahead of its predecessors, by the critics' account. Reviewers praised the plot, and Game Informer said the game had a "better, more focused sense of humor" than earlier Mystery Dungeon games.
That counts for a lot in a game this long. A plot that holds up gives players a reason to push through stretches where the fighting doesn't. The new mechanics drew praise too, so this isn't just the old game with more Pokémon in it.
Why the dungeons wear thin
Underneath all of that is a dungeon crawler built on procedurally generated floors full of enemies and traps. Random layouts should keep things fresh. Critics said they mostly didn't.
- Combat: Game Informer called it overly simple, and the general view was that fights repeat without much change.
- Structure: missions and dungeon runs follow similar patterns, so the repetition goes beyond the fights.
- Comparison: Game Informer said it "pales in comparison" to the core RPG installments of Pokémon.
Nintendo Life's review still ends on a qualified yes. Vogel wrote that players who don't mind grinding through repeated scenarios and battles will find it "pays off in the long run." Read that as a warning about how much patience it asks for, not as a promise of a payoff for everyone.
How it landed
Players showed up anyway. It was the top-selling game in Japan in its debut week, with 151,823 copies sold, and reached about 1.22 million copies worldwide by March 2016. The Academy of Interactive Arts & Sciences also nominated it for Handheld Game of the Year at the 19th D.I.C.E. Awards.
The game is a Nintendo 3DS exclusive, rated Everyone. It came out in Japan on September 17, 2015, in North America on November 20, 2015, and in Europe on February 19, 2016. For a single-player game this long, the rating and the familiar characters make it an easy pick for younger players who already love Pokémon, as long as they can handle a slow, repetitive pace.
Sources
- Wikipedia: Pokémon Super Mystery Dungeon en.wikipedia.org
- Wikidata: Q19962722 wikidata.org