Analysis · Ratchet & Clank

A 2016 reboot that packs 14 years of Ratchet & Clank into one game

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

The idea: the best of the series, rebuilt as one game

Critics described this game as a greatest-hits package. It reimagines the first game in the series from 2002, but it doesn't copy that game. Insomniac Games added pieces from later entries: strafing, weapons and health that upgrade automatically with use, manual weapon upgrades paid for with Raritanium, and weapons that first appeared in later games. IGN's Marty Sliva called it "a culmination" of everything the studio had done with the series over 14 years.

It is also a tie-in to the 2016 film of the same name. The game and the film were both delayed from 2015 to April 2016, partly to give the game more time for polish. Critics noticed that polish. Whether the film tie-in helped the game is less clear, and the later sections come back to it.

The arsenal is where the idea works best

Ratchet fights with a wide spread of weapons and gadgets. Some arrive as the story moves forward, and others you buy from vendors with bolts. Bolts come from crates and defeated enemies, and you also earn them as rewards. New weapons sit beside the older ones, including the Pixelizer, which gives enemies an 8-bit look. The OmniWrench is always on hand as a melee weapon.

Critics praised this part most consistently:

  • IGN called the weapons "creative" and the upgrade systems "rewarding".
  • GameSpot's Cassidee Moser listed the weapons, gadgets, controls and variety among the game's strengths.
  • Game Revolution's Jeb Haught called the gameplay "addictive" and the controls "intuitive".

Getting around adds variety too. You cross gaps with the Swingshot, ride grind rails, walk on magnetic surfaces and solve the odd hacking mini-game. Hoverboard races and spaceship combat missions break up the planet-hopping. This mix is the strongest evidence for the "culmination" pitch: it reads like a sample of many entries in the series.

Smaller in numbers, bigger in polish

A best-of collection has to leave things out, and this one does. Polygon's Philip Kollar pointed out that it has fewer planets and fewer weapons than some earlier entries. He also said its variety and polish keep it from being "dragged down too far." The levels are fairly linear, though many offer more than one path, and new planets open up once you finish story goals on earlier ones.

Some old systems changed. Skill points, a long-running series feature, are gone, and PlayStation trophies take their place. Gold bolts earn cosmetic extras, and holocards fill in background on the world. After the credits, challenge mode raises the difficulty sharply and lets you keep your weapons, which gives the upgrade systems a second run.

Critics also singled out the visuals. Game Informer's Andrew Reiner praised how much action fits on screen at once and how the environments are designed. Sliva called the game "absolutely gorgeous".

Where the greatest-hits approach falls short

The story is the weakest part. Moser called it "under-developed". GamesRadar's Lucas Sullivan pointed to "wonky tie-ins" with the film, and Reiner found some of the dialogue "cringe inducing" even though he liked the soundtrack. A game built partly to promote a movie is retelling a story that also has to work on screen, and critics felt the strain.

Pacing drew the other complaint. Clank's sections drop the guns for punches and environmental puzzles. Reiner said the parts that aren't fast action break up the flow, and Electronic Gaming Monthly's Spencer Campbell said the game gets "bogged down" by slower, more passive segments.

Campbell called it a return to form, but warned that anyone wanting more than that may be disappointed.

That is the honest limit of a culmination. It gathers what already worked. It doesn't reach much further.

Newcomers get the most out of it

VideoGamer.com's Tom Orry thought newcomers would find it fresher than longtime fans, who may notice familiar beats, though he still expected fans to love it. Kollar made a similar point: it should please fans but also win over plenty of new players. It is rated PEGI 7, and at the 20th Annual D.I.C.E. Awards it won Family Game of the Year. That makes it an easy pick for a household with younger players. The critic average, which is calculated from critic scores, is 8.7 out of 10.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet