A 3DS sequel that keeps its predecessor's world and fixes how it plays
Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.
A sequel that stays in the same world
Shin Megami Tensei IV: Apocalypse is Atlus's direct follow-up to Shin Megami Tensei IV. It came out on the Nintendo 3DS in Japan on February 10, 2016, and reached North America on September 20, 2016. It belongs to the Shin Megami Tensei line, the core series of the Megami Tensei franchise, so it carries that series' expectations: hard turn-based fights, demons you recruit, and a world that has already ended.
Atlus didn't build a new world for it. You play the demon hunter Nanashi and move between a post-apocalyptic Tokyo and the medieval kingdom of Mikado. The setting, most of the demons and a large share of the mechanics come straight from the previous game. That decision shapes almost everything critics said about Apocalypse, for and against.
What carried over from IV
The core loop is the one series fans already know. You explore in third person with an overhead world map to help, and fights switch to a first-person view. Battles start from story scenes or when you run into enemy sprites in the field.
Combat uses the Press Turn System, which earlier Shin Megami Tensei games also used. It's built around weaknesses:
- Hit a weak point or land a critical hit and your side gets an extra turn.
- Have an attack absorbed or blocked and you lose turns.
- Ambushes, weakness hits and criticals can trigger Smirk, which raises damage, removes elemental weaknesses and guarantees that the next attack is a critical.
The same rules apply to enemies. One bad matchup can wipe out a party, which is why the series has its reputation.
Demon collecting works the same way too. If a demon doesn't attack right away, you can talk it into joining. Nanashi fields three demons plus an automated Partner who brings their own demon roster. Fusion combines two or more demons into a new one, and you choose which skills carry over. When Nanashi levels up, you put skill points into five stats.
What changed, according to critics
Most of the praise went to the refinements. Critics kept returning to the quality of life upgrades over IV. Jeremy Parish at USGamer praised the gameplay changes, and Luca Forte at Eurogamer Italy pointed to the improved map system. GameSpot's Heidi Kemp was the most enthusiastic, saying the improvements to the core gameplay made demon hunting and exploration much better.
The look also won critics over. Kemp credited the game with an "amazing sense of visual design". Parish called it one of the most "uniquely realistic games on 3DS". Forte described the visuals as detailed and a clear step up from IV. Destructoid's Chris Carter disagreed, calling the graphics "drab" and blaming the limits of the 3DS hardware.
The cost of reusing so much
The biggest criticism was about the world itself. Several reviewers felt the game's universe was too close to IV's. Daniel Tack at Game Informer put it bluntly: apart from the story, "not a whole lot is new."
Whether Apocalypse feels fresh depends on how much of Shin Megami Tensei IV you've already played.
Critics also disagreed about what kind of game it is. Morgan Sleeper at Nintendo Life called it a "sequel-of-sorts". Forte went the other way, saying it was not a sequel or a DLC but "a masterpiece". Both views fit the facts. The skeleton is borrowed, and the story and the smoother systems are where the new work went.
The aggregate scores land between those positions: 85/100 from 38 reviews and 90% from 39. Those numbers say well liked, not universally loved. That matches a game that mostly impressed critics but left some of them wishing it had taken more risks.
Sources
- Wikipedia: Shin Megami Tensei IV: Apocalypse en.wikipedia.org
- Wikidata: Q21076316 wikidata.org