Analysis · Imperator: Rome

A deep Roman strategy game that rewards patience and loses everyone else

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

Critics agreed on the depth and split on what it costs you

Critic scores for Imperator: Rome cover a wide range: a 9/10 on launch day, April 25, 2019, and an aggregate as low as 72/100. The disagreement is less about whether the game is good than about how much it asks of the player.

IGN summed up the tension when it called the amount of strategy packed into the game "equal parts impressive and daunting." The same review praised the depth and criticized the user interface. In a game this dense, the interface decides whether all those systems feel like options or like homework, so that complaint matters.

The same depth that earns the high scores is what keeps the lower ones down.

Players who like learning a system slowly will lean toward the 9/10. Players who want to understand a game in an evening will lean toward the 72.

What the game asks of you

You take control of one nation on a map that runs from the Iberian Peninsula to India. The timeline runs from 304 BCE to 27 BCE, which covers the Wars of the Diadochi and the founding of the Roman Empire. Each province has its own religion and culture, and each one brings different bonuses.

You manage three main resources:

  • Gold, to pay for everything
  • Manpower, to raise and refill armies
  • Political influence, to run your government

On top of those sits a layer of trade goods, such as foods and materials, that move between provinces. Every character also carries Martial, Finesse, Charisma and Zeal stats that decide how well they do their jobs. You aren't moving faceless armies around a map. You're picking which people to trust with them.

The politics are why critics stayed

The part critics praised most is what happens inside your own borders. IGN called the political fights between characters within a nation "a great driver" of character interaction. Rivals, ambitious generals and loyal governors give the empire-building a human side that maps and resource numbers alone don't.

PC Gamer saw the game as a deliberate combination of systems from the studio's recent strategy games. It judged the result more cohesive than a simple greatest-hits collection, which suggests the pieces work together instead of sitting side by side.

The weak spot critics named was the tribal nations. If you want to lead a tribe rather than a settled kingdom or republic, IGN's review suggests those starts are the least developed part of the game.

Players were cooler than critics, and support has ended

User ratings came in lower than Paradox expected, though sales beat the publisher's expectations. That gap fits the critics' split: plenty of people bought the game, and not all of them got past the learning curve.

Development and support were suspended by May 2021, with only occasional patches since then. Treat Imperator: Rome as a finished game. The interface critics complained about isn't going to get a major overhaul, and the tribal nations won't get much more attention. Aggregates dated February 16, 2021, at 74% and 79/100, show where opinion settled close to the end of active development.

It runs on Microsoft Windows, macOS and Linux and supports both single-player and multiplayer.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet