A free Dungeons & Dragons story game for people who skip MMORPGs
Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.
Built for players who usually skip MMORPGs
Neverwinter was made for people who love Dungeons & Dragons stories but don't want the crowds and grind of a traditional MMO. It's free to play and set in the Forgotten Realms city of Neverwinter. You pick one of eight Dungeons & Dragons classes and can team up in groups of up to five.
Its makers pitched it as closer to a single-player story game than a packed online world. You won't be fighting hundreds of strangers for monster spawns, and a strong storyline runs through the whole game. It isn't part of the older Neverwinter Nights series and doesn't require you to know it.
Critics mostly agreed that this pitch worked. Forbes' Daniel Tack wrote that it offered something to players who normally wouldn't play an MMORPG while still giving genre regulars a solid base. VentureBeat's Stephanie Carmichael called it "accessible" to veterans, beginners and casual players alike.
Where it delivers: a free Dungeons & Dragons adventure that kept growing
- Nothing to pay up front. Hardcore Gamer's Jason Bohn pointed out that the PlayStation 4 version doesn't even need a PlayStation Plus subscription. He ranked it among the best MMORPGs available at any price.
- Combat rooted in the tabletop rules. The game started out on a modified version of the 4th edition rules, with healing powers and action points. Its "dailies" let you build up points in a fight and then spend them on a special ability.
- A story that tracked the tabletop game. The Tyranny of Dragons module in August 2014 linked the game to the new 5th Edition. Later modules tied into Elemental Evil, Storm King's Thunder, Tomb of Annihilation, Ravenloft and Undermountain. By April 2019, all eight classes had been rebalanced and renamed to match 5th Edition.
- Quests made by players. A tool called Foundry lets players write their own stories and quests.
There's also a lot of it. Bohn called the game "gigantic" and found reviewing something that size a daunting job.
Where it falls short: console ports and competitive play
The Xbox One version split Polygon's reviewer. The controller layout drew praise for mapping heroes' abilities across the pad in a way that felt good in and out of combat. Polygon also warned that performance could "take a dive" on that console.
GameRant's Boston Blake liked the Xbox One version too, calling it the console's first true MMO. He still flagged frame rate problems and weak PvP, and said it is "not a hardcore MMORPG." For a raid-focused or competitive player, that settles it.
There's also the business model. In October 2011, before launch, the game was rebuilt as a free-to-play MMORPG that sells extra items and other advantages. That matters less if you're playing a story with friends. It matters more if you want to compete with players who are willing to spend.
Rule of thumb: the story and co-op are the reason to play. Don't pick it for a fair PvP ladder.
The scores tell two stories
Early aggregates were steady. The Windows, PlayStation 4 and Xbox One versions each scored 78/100 across nine reviews, another aggregate gave 75/100 from 14 reviews, and Metacritic lists it at 74/100. The critic average of 7.5 out of 10 is calculated from these critic aggregates.
One aggregate shows something else. It stood at 73/100 from 33 reviews in August 2016, then read 45% from 34 reviews by March 8, 2020. The record doesn't explain the drop. It's still a good reason to treat the warm launch-era reviews as describing the game at that time rather than a lasting guarantee.
Sources
- Wikipedia: Neverwinter (video game) en.wikipedia.org
- Wikidata: Q4045284 wikidata.org