A hundred greatest-hit minigames on 3DS, and only one board to play them on
Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.
The last Mario Party on 3DS looked backward
Mario Party: The Top 100 is the fifth handheld game in the series and the third and final one for the Nintendo 3DS. NDcube built it in 2017 as a greatest-hits package: 100 minigames taken from the first 10 Mario Party games for home consoles, most of them with upgraded graphics and audio.
That makes it a different kind of entry. Earlier handheld games tried to be full Mario Party experiences in a smaller box. This one is closer to a museum tour, and critics judged it on whether the tour was worth taking. Many felt the concept was right. Polygon's Allegra Frank called the all-minigame premise "genius", and Destructoid's Caitlin Cooke described it as "a solid trip down nostalgia road".
What changed from the console games
The biggest change is how minigames fit into a board game. In earlier entries, a minigame ran at the end of every turn. In Minigame Match, the only traditional board mode here, minigames start only when a player uses certain items or pops a Minigame Balloon. Players still roll dice and move at the same time, and every 10 coins buys a Star.
Other changes came from the hardware:
- Several Wii minigames were reworked because the 3DS has no motion controls.
- Multiplayer is local only, for up to four players, with Download Play letting one copy serve the group.
- Amiibo support makes new minigames available sooner and adds help during rounds, extra coins and an extra life after a game over.
The control rework drew mixed notes. Nintendo World Report's Matt West wrote that some control schemes did not transfer well to the 3DS and that the minigames felt "somewhat disconnected" in presentation.
One board is where it falls apart
The single board drew the harshest words. West called Minigame Match the game's "biggest disappointment" and its map "pathetically underwhelming", lacking the personality of earlier boards. Hardcore Gamer's Kirstin Swalley agreed it was the most familiar and most fun mode for groups, but said the map "quickly gets dull".
The other modes did not fill the gap. Minigame Island is a linear path of preselected minigames, with occasional duels against Bowser, Donkey Kong and others, and a final fight with Bowser. Several dozen minigames stay locked until players work through it. Nintendo Life's Michael Koczwara called it "a fun but simple mode" that can be finished in two to three hours and offers little reason to replay. Championship Battles, Decathlon and free play round things out, along with a collection menu for music and characters.
"Mario Party: The Top 100 may hold the record for the most minigames, but it certainly has the least amount of content and the lowest replayability." (Nintendo Life)
What it kept, for better and worse
The series' habits came along too. Reviewers again criticized how much winning depends on luck, since the result rests almost entirely on Stars and coins. CGMagazine's Jordan Biordi called the AI "horribly inconsistent" and named the missing online mode the "most glaring problem". He also thought only "maybe 15–20 good minigames" came from three of the first four games.
Not everyone was that harsh about the selection. Koczwara felt the goal of collecting the best minigames was "accomplished with great results", and Common Sense Media's David Wolinsky found most of them approachable. In Japan, Famitsu's four critics each gave it 8 out of 10.
Elsewhere the reception was cool. The main aggregate sits at 60/100 from 34 reviews, OpenCritic counted just 3% of critics recommending it, and the critic average computed from those aggregates is 6.0 out of 10. Digital Trends later ranked it 14th of 18 Mario Party titles. The series did return to this idea: Mario Party Superstars, another 100-minigame collection from the home console games, followed on Switch in 2021.
Sources
- Wikipedia: Mario Party: The Top 100 en.wikipedia.org
- Wikidata: Q39878955 wikidata.org