A Japanese RPG built around walking to whatever you can see
Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.
The promise is a horizon you can actually reach
Japanese RPGs had a reputation for long corridors with cutscenes in between. Xenoblade Chronicles answered that with an open world split into large zones, where you can generally visit whatever you can see in the distance. That openness is what critics kept returning to.
Keza MacDonald, writing for IGN, said the game shocked her out of expecting Japanese RPGs to follow the linear, story-driven model of Final Fantasy XIII. IGN, Eurogamer and Edge all described it as a triumphant comeback for the genre. Most of that praise was written about the 2010 Wii original. This 2020 Switch remaster has its own track record, though: 89/100 across 24 reviews in one aggregate, and 89/100 from 134 reviews in another.
Big zones, few penalties for wandering
A world this large only works if crossing it doesn't become a chore, and most of the design serves that goal:
- Landmarks act as warp points, so you can jump back to any one you've found at any time.
- You can save anywhere outside of battle.
- A full day passes in about ten minutes of real time, and you can set the clock to any hour you want. That matters because some quests, items and stronger enemies only show up at certain times, especially at night.
- New Game+ carries much of your progress into a second run.
Together these features turn exploring into a choice you make freely instead of a cost you pay. That's the open-world idea working as intended.
Combat that looks a few seconds ahead
Battles happen in real time. You control one member of a party of three, and the other two fight on their own. The twist is the hero Shulk's ability to see brief glimpses of the future, which gives fights a planning layer that most action RPGs don't have.
Critics praised the battle system, and several compared it favorably to Final Fantasy XII. The Affinity system feeds into combat too. Party members who fight together, trade gifts or share a Heart-to-Heart scene grow closer, and that bond changes how well they work together in battle.
Quests that respect your time, mostly
Side quests come from the people living in each town. Many of them close out automatically once you meet the goal, with no trip back to the quest giver. Critics singled this out as a user-friendly fix to a common frustration with the genre.
The quests themselves are often simple: collect certain items or defeat a set number of enemies. On top of that come the Collectopaedia (glowing blue orbs scattered across the world that fill a catalog for rewards), a gem-crafting mini-game that uses ether crystals, and town-wide Affinity ratings that open up more story and more quests. Players who like checklists will find plenty here. Players who just want the main plot will need to ignore a lot of glowing distractions.
Where the idea strains
The story starts from what critics called a fairly standard premise. Even so, many found it innovative, and it collected story awards: IGN named it Best Wii/Wii U Story in 2012, and RPGamer gave it Best Story and Best Music alongside its best RPG of the year award. Slant Magazine called it its 2012 Game of the Year.
The one complaint that came up again and again was the graphics. Several critics felt the original lacked the polish of games on other consoles of the time, and the New Nintendo 3DS port drew lower scores because of a graphical downgrade and weak 3D effects. A world built to be looked at is hurt more than most by rough visuals.
The scale was never the problem. The complaints were about how that scale looked, not about how it played.
Sources
- Wikipedia: Xenoblade Chronicles: Definitive Edition en.wikipedia.org
- Wikidata: Q106974926 wikidata.org