Analysis · The Legend of Zelda: A Link Between Worlds

A Link Between Worlds builds a whole Zelda around walking flat on walls

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

One trick: Link becomes a painting

The game is built on one simple idea. Link can press himself into a wall and walk along it as a flat mural. The view swings to the side to follow him around corners, and an energy gauge drains the whole time he stays merged. With that move he crosses gaps, slips past hazards and reaches ledges that look out of reach. He also uses it to pass between Hyrule and its darker twin, Lorule, through cracks that link the two kingdoms.

A Link Between Worlds is a spiritual successor to A Link to the Past, the 1991 Super Nintendo game. It borrows that game's map, many of its items and enemies, and some of its music. Without the wall merge, it would be a remake in new clothes. Most of what critics praised comes back to that one idea.

The puzzles are where the idea pays off

Reviewers praised how wall merging runs through the dungeon puzzles and every area of the map. It isn't saved for a few showpiece rooms. IGN went as far as calling the game Nintendo's best puzzle game. Game Informer wrote that some of its dungeons and boss fights rank among the best in the series.

Critics also liked the difficulty. GameSpot called the challenge perplexing rather than frustrating, which is the right side of that line for a puzzle game. Rooms get solved by seeing them a new way, and often that means looking at the walls.

Polygon called it the best Zelda game in 20 years, and GamesRadar said every 3DS owner should have it.

Renting your tools means choosing your route

The second big change supports the first. In earlier Zelda games, items like the bow, the fire rod and bombs were found inside dungeons. Here Link rents or buys them from a merchant named Ravio. None of them use ammunition. Instead they draw on the same energy gauge as wall merging. If Link dies, his rented items go back to Ravio.

Since the tools are available early, most dungeons can be done in any order. GameSpot called the looser structure a "revelatory change." Game Informer said having items from the start let players experiment in combat. IGN and Polygon both said losing rentals on death added real consequences. Nintendo Life argued that dropping the item hunt left more room for exploring, puzzles and boss fights.

There's one fair objection. GamesRadar missed the excitement of finding a key item deep in a dungeon, a classic Zelda reward that renting gives up.

Where the idea runs thin: a map you may already know

Wall merging opens new paths through the map, but the map itself is old. Hyrule follows A Link to the Past's layout, and Lorule mirrors it the way that game's Dark World did. GamesRadar enjoyed the nostalgia of seeing familiar places again. It also called retracing the same world "somewhat unsatisfying," because the mystery of new ground was gone. Anyone who knows the 1991 game will spend more time recognizing places than discovering them.

The story fared better. Kotaku called it one of the best and darkest in the series, with Link shown in a very different light than in earlier games.

Made for the 3DS's two screens

Reviewers agreed the game made excellent use of the 3DS's 3D effect. It suits a top-down game, where depth shows height and the wall merge turns the view to the side. The top screen holds hearts, the energy gauge and an action prompt. The bottom screen holds the map and item selection, so the main view stays uncluttered.

The art style split critics: some disliked it, and others called it gorgeous. The music won more praise. Game Informer called the soundtrack one of the best in gaming. GamesRadar praised both the new pieces and the reworked tracks from A Link to the Past.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet