Analysis · Super Mario Maker for Nintendo 3DS

A pocket Mario level editor that lost its audience when the servers closed

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

Made for players who would rather build a level than beat one

This is a game for tinkerers. It's a single-player Mario game and a course-building kit in one, rated Everyone and PEGI 3. It suits a young player sketching a first course as well as an older fan who has always wanted to rebuild the courses they grew up on.

You build in four styles: Super Mario Bros., Super Mario Bros. 3, Super Mario World and New Super Mario Bros. U. All four share the physics of the newest one. Enemy behavior and some mechanics change from style to style. Some elements stay locked to one look, while others carry across, so Boos can show up in a Super Mario Bros. course.

For that player, the building tools deliver. The parts that made the series a talking point, like sharing courses and playing what strangers made, are where this version now falls short.

The editor is where critics found the fun

The praise for Super Mario Maker centered on its toolbox. IGN's Jose Otero said its well-designed interface makes learning “easy and intuitive.” GameSpot's Justin Haywald liked how mixing elements produced “exciting and anachronistic additions” to familiar scenes.

The tools go well beyond placing Goombas and warp pipes:

  • Stack enemies on top of each other, or give them wings.
  • Feed an enemy a Super Mushroom to make it giant.
  • Have hazards pop out of question blocks and warp pipes.
  • Let Mario wear a shell as a helmet.
  • Set cannons to fire whatever object you choose.

The Soundfrog adds sound and visual effects. In the Super Mario Bros. style, the Mystery Mushroom dresses Mario in one of 153 costumes. One catch for impatient builders: new editing pieces arrive gradually over nine days of course creation, so the full kit isn't there on day one.

Why the 3DS version scored lower

Metacritic split the two releases. The Wii U version earned “generally favorable” reviews, while this 3DS version landed at “mixed or average.” The aggregate here is 72/100 from 56 reviews, published alongside a much lower 38% figure. The critic average of 7.2, computed from those critic numbers, sits at the same level.

The record doesn't spell out what pulled the 3DS version down, so read the gap as a warning rather than a diagnosis. Some limits apply to the series as a whole. Haywald was let down that the checkpoints from Super Mario World were missing, and that stages are capped in both height and length. Ambitious builders will run into those walls.

The sharing side no longer exists

Much of what critics loved happened online. Finished courses went up to Course World. The 100 Mario Challenge strung together random player-made courses with 100 lives. Stars from other players earned medals, and medals let you upload more courses. Otero said players would see “a genuine reverence for Mario's history” in those online modes.

That community grew in directions Nintendo didn't plan for. Mario co-creator Takashi Tezuka said players didn't share Nintendo's restraint about difficulty, and the series helped revive the Kaizo scene of punishing, patience-testing courses. It had friction too: Kotaku's Patrick Klepek criticized Nintendo for removing players' courses without warning or explanation.

The 3DS and Wii U servers shut down in April 2024. What remains is building on your own and the 10 Mario Challenge, a set of pre-made courses with only 10 lives.

Buy this one to make courses, not to find them.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet