A slow island life sim that rewards daily visits, not marathon sessions
Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.
Made for players who want a small daily ritual
New Horizons is for players who like a game they can return to for a short visit each day. It runs on the real-world clock, and its seasons follow your own hemisphere, a first for the series. Fish, bugs and sea creatures come and go with the time of year. You move to a deserted island on a getaway package from Tom Nook, then turn it into a town with shops, a museum and animal neighbors.
That kind of player is who critics had in mind. On Switch the game earned "universal acclaim" on Metacritic, the highest rating of any game in the series, and Nintendo Life and Pocket Gamer both gave it perfect scores. The critic average, worked out from those critic scores, is 9.0 out of 10.
Where it delivers: an island that looks like its owner
Most of the praise went to how much the game lets you decide. You gather wood, fruit and rocks and turn them into furniture through D.I.Y. crafting, and Nintendo Life pointed out that no resource goes to waste. GameSpot and Game Informer liked being able to choose where buildings and bridges go. The Island Designer App drew credit for letting you reshape rivers and cliffs.
Nook Miles, a currency earned for small tasks, gave reviewers a steady list of goals. Pocket Gamer's Dann Sullivan liked its "optional direction", and USGamer joked that nobody could say there was nothing to do. Polygon's Russ Frushtick said a finished island becomes a "true representation of the player who created it." TechRadar praised the look and sound as a big step up from earlier games in the series.
Where it falls short: a slow start and a low ceiling
The real-time clock that makes daily visits feel good also makes the first stretch drag. Resources refill overnight, and reviewers found little to do in the opening days. IGN's Samuel Claiborn, who had never changed the clock in earlier games, ended up moving it 15 days ahead to reach the point where more tools become available. 4Players saw it the other way, liking the lack of pressure and the option to skip ahead.
The other end of the game drew sharper complaints. The credits roll when the island reaches three stars and K.K. Slider plays a concert. Looking back a year later, The Verge and iMore agreed that progress stops after a few months, which makes coming back hard. The Verge called Nook Miles "an afterthought" by then. Both still enjoyed the daily chores as a small escape.
Players who spent long hours early on tended to burn out by six weeks in, according to Vice and VentureBeat. The game works better in short visits.
Slant Magazine's Steven Scaife raised a different worry: giving one player so much control, he argued, cuts against the series' idea of shared community life.
Sharing one console is the weak spot
Families should know this before buying. Only one player per console gets the full game, and the way it handles Switch profiles and multiplayer led to review bombing. A second person in the same house plays a smaller role on the same island. Online visits to friends' islands, on the other hand, were a highlight, and WIRED's Louryne Strampe wrote about finding comfort in visiting colleagues' islands during lockdown.
The expansion helps more than the Switch 2 edition
The Happy Home Paradise expansion was well received. Kotaku's Lisa Segarra called designing villager homes "exhilarating", and Nintendo Life's Kate Gray compared the expansion and free update to "a big lick of paint over the whole game." Critics did note that it was billed as the final update.
The Nintendo Switch 2 edition, released January 15, 2026, got "generally favorable" reviews. Nintendo Life's Alex Olney found a higher resolution but the same 30 fps frame rate, and called it "not an especially exciting upgrade." If you already own the Switch version, there's little reason to upgrade.
Sources
- Wikipedia: Animal Crossing: New Horizons en.wikipedia.org
- Wikidata: Q64566657 wikidata.org