Analysis · No Rest for the Wicked

A Soulslike seen from above, still in early access until March 2027

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

Two critic numbers that point different ways

In May 2024, a month after the game reached early access, a critic aggregate of 17 reviews put it at 73/100. On May 6, 2025, the same aggregator showed 47% across 18 reviews. The two figures measure different things, so they can't be compared directly. Still, they tell a consistent story: a 73/100 average next to a figure under half points to many critics who found real strengths but stopped short of a clear recommendation.

The critic average, computed from those aggregates, is 7.3 out of 10. The reviews published so far don't record what each critic argued. The game's design and its status do explain why opinions would land in the middle. It came out on Windows through early access on April 18, 2024. The full release is scheduled for PC and PlayStation 5 in March 2027, and Nintendo Switch 2 and Xbox Series X/S versions are planned for later. Critics reviewed something unfinished, and that tends to produce exactly this kind of hedged result.

Every swing, roll and block costs stamina

Combat borrows heavily from Soulslike games, played from a top-down view. You can strike, parry, dodge-roll and block, and every one of those actions drains stamina. That makes fights deliberate. You can't mash through them, and each move is a small bet.

Your armor changes how you move as well as how much damage you take. Agile armor gives you a quick sidestep that dodges attacks for little stamina, so gear choices shape your fighting style and not just your numbers. Focus builds up during a fight and pays out as a special attack once it reaches a threshold.

Death is softer than the genre's usual rules:

  • You respawn at the nearest Cerim Whisper point with full health.
  • Enemies you already killed stay dead.
  • Wounded enemies don't heal while you're gone.

That last rule matters. A hard fight becomes a war of attrition you can win across several tries, which makes the game more approachable than its stamina system first suggests. Progress comes from attribute points spread across seven areas: health, strength, stamina, dexterity, faith, intelligence and focus. A "soft class" system lets you change playstyles without starting over.

Sacrament rewards the players who stick around

The other side of the game is the city of Sacrament, which changes as you finish side objectives. You can buy a house and decorate it. Resources you gather in the wilderness go into new gear, furniture or improvements to the town, and hidden chests and materials sit off the main path.

Between missions there's fishing and farming. After the main campaign, an endgame mode called Cerim Crucible pits you against the toughest enemies in the game.

This loop is where the game will win some players over and wear others out. If you enjoy collecting materials and watching a place grow, Sacrament gives the combat a reason to keep going. If you want a tight action game that ends cleanly, the crafting and gathering will feel like busywork between fights.

Who should buy now and who should wait

The game's split personality explains the middling critic numbers. One half is a punishing action game where stamina is everything. The other is a slow-burn life-sim layer of houses, crops and town upgrades. Players who want both will get the most from it. Players who want only one will keep running into the other.

Buying early access means paying for the game as it is now, not as it's planned to be.

That applies especially to multiplayer. 4-player co-op and player-versus-player modes are listed as planned, so anyone buying mainly to play with friends should hold off until those are confirmed in the full release. Solo players who like deliberate fights and gear-driven builds have a clearer case for buying now.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet