A story critics ranked among the best ever, with combat that split them
Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.
Best game ever made, or a brawler with thin combat
Nintendo World Report's Melanie Zawodniak gave Nier: Automata a perfect score and called it one of the best games ever made because of its narrative and gameplay design. The sharpest criticism came from the other direction. Several critics felt its combat lacked depth next to earlier PlatinumGames titles, and Game Informer's Joe Juba wrote that confusing or obtuse mechanics hide many of the good parts of its story and gameplay.
Both camps were describing the same game, one whose ambitions run ahead of its systems. Most critics decided the ambition was worth it. The original PS4 release earned "generally favorable reviews" across 107 critics on Metacritic, and the Xbox One version reached "universal acclaim" with a 90 from 30 reviews. The critic average, computed from five critics, is 8.6 out of 10.
The story is why it keeps landing on best-of lists
Critics praised the story and its themes more than anything else in the game. Famitsu gave it a near-perfect score and singled out the themes. GamesRadar+'s Sam Prell was enthusiastic about the narrative, and Polygon's Janine Hawkins praised the game's sense of scale and its willingness to make players feel small.
The structure is unusual. There are 26 endings: five main ones lettered A to E, plus 21 more lettered F through Z. Those extra endings work as game over events, and the game triggers them when players take certain actions, fail to move the story forward or lose certain battles. The story also passes between three protagonists, 2B, 9S and A2.
Not every critic connected with it. Some found the pacing and presentation lacking, and both IGN's Meghan Sullivan and Eurogamer's Jeffrey Matulef found the android protagonists hard to relate to. Matulef still called the game captivating despite its rough edges. That was the usual pattern: critics noted the flaws, then praised the game anyway.
Combat that borrows from the best but stops short
Fights happen in real time and mix light and heavy attacks into combos. Dodging at the right moment gives a moment of invulnerability or a counterattack bonus, and a flying Pod robot adds ranged attacks that can be customized. Each protagonist fights differently:
- 2B switches between two weapons.
- 9S mixes light attacks with hacking into enemies.
- A2 can sacrifice health for a short boost to her attack power.
GameSpot's Miguel Concepcion called the gameplay "the closest thing there is to a spiritual successor" to Metal Gear Rising: Revengeance, and Destructoid's Chris Carter called it a competent blend of action game and RPG. The variety comes from switching genres more than from depth. The camera moves to top-down or side-scrolling views for shoot 'em up sections, and other stretches turn into text adventures, platforming or flying mech battles.
The criticism is that none of this goes very deep. Nintendo Life's Thomas Whitehead liked the design but said some gameplay elements don't work as expected and lack depth. Upgrades come from chips that fit a limited number of slots and can change the HUD, add abilities or grant buffs. The four difficulty settings can be changed at any time.
If combat depth is why you play PlatinumGames titles, trust the critics who found it missing here. If the story is the draw, Easy mode offers chips that automate attacking, dodging and Pod fire.
Critics loved the music and kept noticing the tech problems
Critics agreed on the music without exception, and the reviews call it unanimously acclaimed. Most critics also liked the visuals, though some pointed to poor-quality environments in places.
Technical problems came up again and again: graphical pop-in, frame-rate drops and long loading times. PC Gamer's Andy Kelly liked the game but criticized the PC port for graphical and technical issues at release. The Switch version was named one of the best third-party ports on that system, though reviewers noted performance issues and downgraded graphics they had expected. The game is rated Mature 17+ and PEGI 18.
Sources
- Wikipedia: Nier: Automata en.wikipedia.org
- Wikidata: Q21078985 wikidata.org