Analysis · Mario & Luigi: Superstar Saga + Bowser's Minions

A turn-based RPG where every enemy attack asks you to press a button

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

Made for players who get bored waiting on menus

This is a role-playing game for players who like levels, gear and stat choices but lose interest during the waiting half of a turn-based fight. It's rated Everyone and stars Mario and Luigi. The brothers travel to the Beanbean Kingdom to stop Cackletta and Fawful, who stole Princess Peach's voice to use the power of an artifact called the Beanstar.

The game first came out on Game Boy Advance in 2003 and started the Mario & Luigi series. This Nintendo 3DS version arrived on October 5, 2017, with Bowser's Minions added to its name. Critics scored the 3DS release 82/100 across 48 reviews, which works out to a critic average of 8.2. For the player it was made for, that score is earned. Someone who wants a hard or inventive RPG will probably rate it lower, for reasons covered below.

Fights where you never just watch

Each brother has his own button: A for Mario, B for Luigi. That split runs through everything. In battle, a well-timed press adds an extra jump or powers up a hammer swing. When an enemy attacks, a timed jump or hammer lets the brothers dodge and sometimes hit back, such as by landing on a charging Goomba.

Choosing the right attack matters too. Jumping on spiked or burning enemies hurts the brothers, and hammers miss anything that flies. Each brother also has an elemental hand power, fire for Mario and thunder for Luigi, that some enemies resist and others are weak to. Bros. Attacks spend Bros. Points on combined moves that need both brothers in sync, and you can't use them while one brother is knocked out.

IGN's Craig Harris praised a battle system that "involves the player at all times." That's the main reason to pick this over a slower RPG.

The overworld uses the same two-button idea. Luigi's hammer can squash Mario small enough to fit through gaps, and putting Mario on Luigi's shoulders lets them hover across wide ones. Hitting an enemy on the map before it touches you starts the fight with damage already dealt or the enemy stunned. It also works the other way round.

The jokes are what critics remembered

Critics liked the writing most of all. Eurogamer's Tom Bramwell said every line and cameo was handled with "a loving sense of humour." Reviewers also liked that it nodded to Mario's history while steering clear of the series' usual clichés. The visuals, setting and animation were well received, and the music was praised for mixing new tunes with nostalgic ones.

Not everyone liked the story. RPGamer's Andrew Long called the plot repetitive and the characters "a tad shallow." If the banter doesn't land for you, nothing else in the game makes up for it.

Where it lets down anyone who wants a challenge

The complaints were as consistent as the praise. Most come from reviews of the 2003 original, which is the version critics wrote about in detail:

  • It's easy. Some reviewers thought the difficulty was set low to suit a younger audience.
  • It isn't new. GameSpy argued that its gameplay offered little that earlier Mario and Zelda games on the NES and SNES hadn't.
  • Two brothers, a lot of buttons. Edge and other outlets found the controls confusing at times when switching between jumps, hammers and combined moves.
  • The view hides things. A common complaint was that the overhead camera made it hard to judge paths and to tell where objects sat against the background.
  • The music repeats. Critics liked the tracks but noted they loop often.

The 3DS release's 82/100 shows critics still rated the game highly in 2017. Nothing in the record says these weak spots were fixed, so expect them to still be there.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet