A vast 18th-century war map held back by an unreliable AI opponent
Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.
Critics called it a landmark and flagged a broken AI
PC Gamer UK went as far as calling Empire one of the most "playable, important and accomplished" games ever made. GamePro was the main dissenter. It said the game had "a heap of problems" and pointed to bugs and crashes. Crispy Gamer called it "spectacular" but concluded that its bad AI makes it fall apart.
Most critics sided with the first view. Metacritic reported "universal acclaim", critic aggregates put the game at 92/100 across 18 reviews, and a separate review published March 13, 2009 scored it 8/10. The critic average, computed from those critic scores, is 9.2.
Nearly every review follows the same pattern. The strategy map gets the loudest praise and the land battles hold up well. Most of the complaints are about the sea battles and the computer opponent.
The campaign map is huge, and that is the reason to play
Empire is the fifth Total War game, released March 3, 2009, and it moves the series to the 18th century. As in earlier entries, it has two halves. One is a turn-based campaign where you move armies and fleets, trade, spy and manage your nation's politics. The other is real-time battles on land and at sea. Each campaign turn covers six months.
The map is wide. Over fifty factions appear and eleven are playable, from Great Britain, France and Prussia to the Ottoman Empire and the Maratha Confederacy. Play covers Europe, the Middle East, India, North America and the Caribbean, plus trade zones off South America, Africa and the East Indies.
Critics kept coming back to that size. Kieron Gillen, writing for Eurogamer, called the map "endless" and finished a whole campaign without visiting India, roughly a quarter of the world. He saw that as a reason to play again. GameSpot noted that even a short 50-year campaign takes real time, because every turn asks for thinking on several fronts at once. PC Gamer UK said the design borrows from the trends of the era, so factions face problems close to those of their real counterparts.
Reviewers also liked the cleaner interface and the new technology tree. GameSpy called it the most accessible Total War yet and a good place for newcomers to start. The story campaign, "Road to Independence", helps with that. Its three structured chapters run from the founding of Jamestown to the War of Independence and double as a tutorial. Finishing it makes the United States playable in a shorter campaign.
Gunpowder makes the land battles the safe bet
Critics rated the real-time land battles highly. GameSpy said personal firearms and friendly fire change the tactics "much as it did in real life", and it found both the controls and the enemy AI competent. IGN praised the improved formation controls and a cinematic feel that skips obvious exaggeration. GameSpot called the battles "enjoyable to command and enjoyable to watch" and singled out the detailed model and animation for every soldier.
The problems show up in the details. GameSpot said the AI could look "confused", and Game Informer's second-opinion review said it "falls apart from time to time". Eurogamer faulted unit pathfinding during fort sieges, and Game Informer criticized pathfinding around obstacles.
At sea, the view is better than the controls
Naval combat got more criticism than anything else in the game. PC Format called the visuals "incredible" but said real naval tactics go out the window while you fight to bring your cannons to bear. IGN found it rewarding to line up ships, use the wind and pick targets, but faulted the formations and pathfinding. GameSpot said the AI seemed unable to manage a sea battle with much success.
PC Gamer UK shared the complaint but was forgiving, calling naval strategy a "deeply difficult task" for any developer.
In practice, critics found the sea battles impressive to watch but less satisfying to command than the fights on land.
The computer opponent is the weak link
The campaign AI drew the most pointed criticism. 1UP.com described illogical choices such as an occasional "suicidal war" between Dagestan and Russia. GamePro said the AI couldn't mount a naval invasion or use effective strategies on the campaign map. Eurogamer said these issues limit the game to "merely one of the games of the year" and suggested a patch could fix them.
Even critics who found faults recommended the game. IGN said it "drags a bit" but still belongs alongside the greatest games ever made. 1UP.com called it "undoubtedly progress", and GameSpot summed it up as "complex and rewarding". Game Watcher was cooler on The Warpath Campaign add-on: it criticized the campaign for not fitting into the main game and for adding only a few units, though it liked the challenge of playing as the Native Americans.
Sources
- Wikipedia: Empire: Total War en.wikipedia.org
- Wikidata: Q839088 wikidata.org