A war game that trades the soldier's rifle for a civilian's empty pantry
Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.
The studio's turn from the battlefield to the basement
The Polish team at 11 Bit Studios developed and published this game itself and released it in November 2014. It came after the studio's Anomaly: Warzone Earth (2011) and before the games that followed it: Frostpunk in 2018, Frostpunk 2 in 2024 and The Alters in 2025.
The war setting stayed. The point of view changed. The game draws on the siege of Sarajevo among other conflicts, but it skips frontline combat entirely. Instead it follows civilians trying to outlast a siege in the fictional city of Pogoren, Graznavia. Most of them have no military training and no survival skills, and the game asks you to keep them alive anyway.
That one change shapes everything else. Survival depends on finding a can of food and a dry place to sleep, not on how well you aim.
Days indoors, nights in the rubble
The structure is a strict daily cycle. Snipers keep the survivors inside during the day, so daylight goes to work in the shelter:
- crafting tools from scavenged materials
- cooking, trading and healing the wounded
- upgrading the damaged house they're hiding in
At night a survivor can go out and search nearby buildings. That's where other civilians turn up, and where the hardest choices sit: you can share food and medicine with them, rob them or kill them. A radio built in the shelter brings weather warnings, news of the city's economy and updates on the war, which helps you plan the next upgrade or the next scavenging run.
You start with one to four people out of twelve playable characters. Each has one or two traits. Bruno is a "Good Cook" who uses less fuel and water at the stove, and Roman is a former rebel trained in combat. Hidden stats also affect fighting and movement speed. Health, hunger and mood all need watching, and the ceasefire arrives after a randomized stretch, so you never know how long you have to hold out. Each survivor's ending depends on what you chose for them.
The Little Ones DLC adds a child who at first can't defend themselves or help run the shelter. The adults can teach the child small jobs like cooking, filtering water and growing crops. It's an extra mouth to feed that you can't skip caring for.
Why critics kept coming back to something so bleak
Metacritic rated the PC and console versions "generally favorable" and the iOS version "universal acclaim". The aggregate scores sit between 83/100 and 87%, and the critic average, which is calculated from those critic aggregates, is 8.4 out of 10.
Critics who liked it kept saying the same thing: the misery pulled them back in. The Digital Fix gave the PC version nine out of ten and said a real tactical survival game sits under the moral message, one that had its reviewer retrying to save the group. Digital Spy gave it four stars out of five and credited its "earnest human touch" for keeping it compelling even after a run fell apart.
411Mania gave the Xbox One version 8.5 out of 10 and said it was "not much fun to actually play". It still urged readers to try it.
The game was also nominated for Outstanding Achievement in Story at the 18th Annual D.I.C.E. Awards, which fits a game whose story comes from the choices you make.
Where the approach loses people
The objections came from the same place as the praise. Metro UK gave the PS4 version seven out of ten and called it a daring attempt that works as interactive drama even when it "occasionally fails as a game". Slant Magazine went much further, giving it two stars out of five and accusing it of piling on human despair for its own sake.
So reviewers didn't really disagree about what the game does. They disagreed about whether making a player feel terrible counts as an achievement. If you need your games to reward you, the critics who disliked it probably describe what you'd get. If you think a game can be worth your time without being fun, most critics landed on your side.
The audience never left. The developer's publishing director said sales kept growing five years after launch, helped by the console and mobile releases, and the game had passed 9 million copies across all platforms by January 2024.
Sources
- Wikipedia: This War of Mine en.wikipedia.org
- Wikidata: Q16743212 wikidata.org