Analysis · The Walking Dead: Season One

A zombie game that's really about keeping one girl alive

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

Everything hangs on keeping Clementine safe

The Walking Dead: Season One asks one thing of you, over and over: keep a young girl named Clementine alive as a zombie apocalypse spreads across Georgia. You play Lee Everett, a convicted criminal who becomes her guardian, and nearly every system in the game exists to test that relationship. Critics praised the harsh emotional tone, the cast and the story. What they singled out most was the connection between Lee and Clementine.

That was the plan from the start. The game is set in the same universe as Robert Kirkman's comic series, and Kirkman described it as a game about characters and story. It sets aside the action habits of other zombie games. IGN's Greg Miller called the result "something special."

Your choices bend people, not a morality meter

Most of the game is making decisions. Conversations offer several replies, and some have to be picked before a timer runs out. If the timer runs down, Lee stays silent, and the other survivors notice. Each episode also builds to points where you must pick between two options, and the outcomes carry over from one episode to the next.

What sets this apart from games that score you on a good-or-evil scale is that the results are ambiguous. A choice doesn't make Lee a hero or a villain. It shifts how the people around him feel about him. That serves the core idea well, since protecting Clementine means deciding who to trust, and the game won't tell you which answer was right.

Two options change how that feels:

  • Minimal mode turns off hints and the notification that flags when a character's attitude toward Lee has changed.
  • Rewind and multiple saves let you go back and make a different decision.

Minimal mode suits the game's intent best. Rewind is handy for seeing other outcomes, but it takes some of the sting out of the harsh tone critics responded to.

The puzzles and action are the weakest link

Between conversations, you move Lee around in third person and use an on-screen reticle to examine people and objects. You progress by solving environmental puzzles, using items you've collected and talking to the right character. MTV described these as "not-too-hard puzzles," and that fits a game whose real interest lies elsewhere.

Action scenes run on quick time events. Miss the prompts and Lee or someone else dies, and the game restarts from just before the sequence. These moments keep the tension up without asking for much skill. Measured against the core idea, they deliver danger rather than a real challenge.

Technical glitches drew the clearest complaints from critics. Eurogamer's Oli Welsh summed up the mixed side of the response, calling the game serious and solid but "clay-footed." If the story holds you, the rough edges are easy to forgive. If you want an adventure game with satisfying puzzles, they won't be.

The story got stronger as the season went on

The season came out in five episodes, plus a DLC episode called 400 Days, between April 2012 and July 2013. Episode-by-episode Metacritic scores show critics warming as it built toward its end:

  • Episode 1, A New Day: 79 to 84/100 depending on platform
  • Episode 2, Starved for Help: 84/100 on all three platforms
  • Episode 3, Long Road Ahead: 85 to 88/100
  • Episode 4, Around Every Corner: 80 to 82/100, the season's dip
  • Episode 5, No Time Left: 88 to 89/100, and critical acclaim
  • 400 Days: 78 to 80/100

The finale scoring highest fits the core idea. A game built on a bond pays off most when that bond is tested hardest. GameSpot saw it coming at the midpoint, expecting the series to keep improving toward an "inevitably depressing" conclusion.

The full season holds 89/100 at Metacritic from 14 reviews. USA Today, Wired, GamesRadar+, Official Xbox Magazine, Destructoid and Digital Trends were among the outlets that named it Game of the Year. The critic average of 6.5 out of 10 comes from a smaller critic aggregate of three reviews per platform, so it reads lower than the wider reception.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet