Analysis · Against the Storm

Against the Storm makes you abandon every city, and critics loved it for that

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

Critics agreed on the score but not on the genre

Critics barely disagreed about quality. Aggregate scores sit between 89 and 91 out of 100 on every platform, Eurogamer gave it a perfect score, and 95% of critics on one aggregator recommended it. The published reviews don't say what the holdouts disliked. Where reviewers split was on what kind of game they were praising.

One group reviewed it as a city builder that breaks its genre's habits. Eurogamer called it "one of the most novel and well-crafted city builders", and PC Gamer liked how its premise overturns the usual city-building conventions. The other group treated it as a hybrid. PCGamesN praised its mix of roguelike, strategy and small-scale city building. Rock Paper Shotgun found the two halves "surprisingly compatible", and Ars Technica went furthest, calling it a "rogue-ultralite".

That split tells you more than the scores do, because it shows which players might not get along with it.

Every city is built to be lost

Each run starts in a calm period, when the storm eases. You build a village near the Smoldering City and push back a forest that corrupts anything inside it. You also gather resources from that forest and turn them into food, fuel and building materials. Maps, resources, population and available buildings are all procedurally generated, so no two villages start the same way. When the calm ends, the storm destroys every settlement and a new map is generated.

Your villagers come from seven species: Humans, Beavers, Harpies, Lizards and Foxes, plus Frogs and Bats, which are only in the paid expansion (DLC). Each species has its own needs and specialties, and each village gets only three of them. Villages also come with set tasks, and those get harder when the resources you need aren't close by. If villagers are unhappy they leave, and if food runs out they starve. You get workers back by clearing events or from the caravan that arrives each year.

The win condition is a race between two gauges:

  • Reputation fills as you keep villagers happy and complete tasks. Fill it and you clear the map.
  • Queen's Impatience fills over time. If it fills first, the Queen recalls you, though each reputation gain pushes it back a little.

Unlocked abilities carry over between runs, as in other roguelites. You can also collect seal fragments, which open a special map. Reforging a seal there for the first time weakens the storm and makes the calm period last longer.

The short city is the selling point

Rock Paper Shotgun picked out the feature that sets it apart: each city has clear goals and takes about an hour, where most city builders run without end. Sports Illustrated made the same point, saying it packs the best parts of city building into a short, addictive game. Ars Technica added that the brevity doesn't cost depth, praising its strategic options and replayability.

This is the game's biggest strength and also the reason some players won't like it. Bad early choices only cost you one village, and the next map gives you fresh constraints, so there's always a new problem to solve. But you never get to watch one city grow over a long campaign, because ending each city is the whole design.

If you enjoy finishing a city more than admiring it, this was made for you.

Where it could lose you

The published reviews have no serious complaints, so these concerns come from the design rather than from any critic:

  • The clock never stops. Queen's Impatience means you're always being timed. Players who build to relax will feel pushed.
  • The procedural maps can work against you. Tasks can call for resources that aren't easy to reach, and some runs will feel harder than others.
  • Two of the seven species cost extra. Frogs and Bats are in the DLC only.
  • It's single-player only. There's no shared or competitive mode.

None of these is a flaw if you want short, tense runs, and the critics who reviewed it as a hybrid clearly did. If you come to it as a traditional city builder, these are where the friction is. It's out on Microsoft Windows, and since June 26, 2025 on PlayStation 4, PlayStation 5, Xbox One, Xbox Series X and Series S, and Nintendo Switch. Critics scored all versions about the same.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet