Age of Calamity's fighting won critics over, but its story split them
Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.
The story is where critics parted ways
Critics mostly agreed about the fighting. They disagreed about the story and about how the game uses its source. Shacknews' TJ Denzer gave it 9/10. He praised the story along with the gameplay and called it the most fleshed-out, well-crafted Dynasty Warriors-style game. Electronic Gaming Monthly's Michael Goroff scored it 4 out of 5 and liked the gameplay just as much, but he was critical of the story's choice to bring in time travel.
That split matters more than usual because Age of Calamity is a spin-off of The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild (2017). Much of its appeal depends on how you feel about a story that builds on that game. One critic read it as a well-told expansion. Another felt a plot device undercut it.
Borrowing Breath of the Wild helps and hurts
Screen Rant's Scott Baird, who gave the game 4/5, captured both sides in one review. He praised it for offering a "fascinating look" at Breath of the Wild's setting. He also said that setting "severely limits" the kinds of enemies you meet compared with the first Hyrule Warriors, and that new touches such as elemental versions of monsters felt less than impressive.
Denzer saw only the upside. He said the game expands on Breath of the Wild masterfully, both in its well-known battle locations and in the music that goes with them. The borrowing goes beyond looks:
- The Sheikah Slate and the paraglider come back.
- The map resembles Breath of the Wild's, and you choose stages from it.
- A Sheikah Tower lets you explore between regions.
- You cook food for buffs and solve environmental puzzles.
One change runs the other way. Weapons here never break, unlike in Breath of the Wild.
Crowd battles with a long list of fighters
Under the Zelda trappings, this is a Dynasty Warriors-style hack and slash. You fight large battles against crowds of enemies while you complete objectives, capture bases and command troops. Between fights, you craft materials, upgrade weapons, spend resources to open new areas and take on missions and challenges. Characters can reach level 100.
There are 18 playable characters. You get 14 of them through the main story, and side quests add the other four. You can also take control of the giant Divine Beasts and wipe out huge numbers of enemies at once. Denzer and Baird both singled out how differently the characters play. Baird said the combat rarely feels repetitive or dull and pointed to "hundreds of hours worth of content".
Baird's main gameplay complaint was the camera, which he said "tends to get stuck" in indoor stages, especially while you're trying to dodge.
What the split says about who'll enjoy it
The aggregates are steady. Metacritic has it at 78 out of 100, OpenCritic reports that 78% of critics recommend it, and four Famitsu reviewers gave it 36/40. The critic average of 7.9 is calculated from those critic aggregates. Behind those numbers, critics agreed on the combat and split on the rest. That points to two kinds of player.
If Breath of the Wild is a favorite and you'll accept a story that takes liberties with it, critics' praise lines up with what you want: familiar places, familiar music, the paraglider and a large roster with real differences between fighters. If you're mainly after the story, Goroff's objection is the one to weigh. If you loved the enemy variety in the first Hyrule Warriors, take Baird's warning seriously. The game holds back on enemy types to stay true to its setting.
It supports both single-player and multiplayer, and it works with figures of the four Champions, which were rereleased alongside the game.
Sources
- Wikipedia: Hyrule Warriors: Age of Calamity en.wikipedia.org
- Wikidata: Q98969837 wikidata.org