Age of Empires IV rebuilds Age of Empires II for a new decade and rarely strays
Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.
Made for the player who never stopped playing Age of Empires II
Age of Empires IV was built for real-time strategy players who know the classic Age of Empires rhythm by heart: gather wood, food, gold and stone, grow a town, advance through the ages, then send an army out. Relic Entertainment made it with World's Edge, and Xbox Game Studios published it. It's the first entry in the series not developed by Ensemble Studios, and the second set in the Middle Ages after Age of Empires II.
That second fact shapes the whole game. Play is mostly similar to Age of Empires II, and the four ages carry over unchanged: Dark, Feudal, Castle and Imperial. The setting runs from the Early Middle Ages to the early Renaissance, and the earliest civilization appears in the year 750. If that list of ages feels like home, you're the reader this game was made for.
It also tries to bring in newcomers. PCGamesN's Ian Boudreau called the Art of War tutorials "hugely helpful" for new players learning how to run an economy. Single-player, co-op and multiplayer modes are all here.
Where it delivers: civilizations that play like different games
The clearest win is variety between sides. Rachel Weber of GamesRadar+ wrote that each civilization was "meticulously designed" to play differently. Robert Zak of PC Gamer called the visual and strategic variety the fourth entry's greatest triumph and one of the biggest changes in the series.
The design backs that up. Most civilizations share a core roster of farms, barracks, keeps and walls, but each can swap in replacement buildings that do the same job differently, and some get unique buildings of their own. Moving to the next age doesn't happen at the Town Center. Instead you build a Landmark, which turns a menu click into a choice about what kind of town you want.
The roster has also grown a lot. Eight civilizations shipped on October 28, 2021. The Ottomans and Malians arrived free on 25 October 2022, and paid expansions have since taken the count to 25, several of them "variant civilizations" that rework existing ones. Polygon argued that trimming Age of Empires II's mechanics helped, because the difficulty comes from decisions rather than finger work.
Campaigns that teach history, with the rough parts left out
The single-player campaigns stay close to real events:
- The Normans (1066 to 1217)
- The Hundred Years War (1351 to 1450)
- The Rise of Moscow (1238 to 1552)
- The Mongol Empire (1223 to 1273)
- The Sultans Ascend and Yue Fei's Legacy, sold as expansions
Critics liked how much history they carry. Game Informer praised the history videos between missions, GameSpot's Darryn Bonthuys singled out how educational the campaign is, and VG247 said the commitment to accuracy makes it more than "another medieval combat simulator." The Washington Post praised the balance of the battles themselves, saying each one could tip either way at any moment.
The catch came from PC Gamer. Zak felt the game whitewashes history, and that its "squeaky-clean presentation" avoids the uglier parts of the period it teaches.
Where it falls short: a sequel that plays it safe
If you want a strategy game that rethinks the genre, this isn't it. IGN called it an enjoyable throwback that often "plays it too safe." Game Informer went further, saying it shows no ambition to challenge the standards Age of Empires II set decades earlier. GameSpot also found the visuals dated and said the game "rarely ventures out of its comfort zone."
Not everyone saw that as a flaw. CGMagazine's Hayes Madsen gave it 10/10 and called it a bold evolution of the series. The game also won Best Sim/Strategy Game at The Game Awards 2021 and Strategy/Simulation Game of the Year at the 25th Annual D.I.C.E. Awards.
The aggregates sit in between. Metacritic reports "generally favorable" reviews, and 82% of critics on OpenCritic recommend it. The critic average, calculated from those critic aggregates, is 8.1 out of 10. The split is easy to read: critics who wanted the classic formula done well were happy, and critics who wanted something new were let down.
Sources
- Wikipedia: Age of Empires IV en.wikipedia.org
- Wikidata: Q55154676 wikidata.org