Alienation pairs some of the best twin-stick shooting with a thin loot grind
Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.
Superb shooting, but a loop that never quite clicks
Alienation's best review and its harshest one pull in opposite directions. Destructoid's Jordan Devore called it "one of the best-feeling twin-stick shooters" he had played. The reviewers at gamesTM thought Housemarque failed to join its two hooks: a loot system built on grinding, and replaying stages to raise your score. In their view, the mix had neither the "purity or compulsion" of either one.
Both can be true, and the scores suggest most critics sided with Devore. The game holds 79 out of 100 on Metacritic, and the critic average, computed from the critic aggregates, is 7.9 out of 10.
The setup is simple. Aliens have invaded Earth, and one to four players fight them from an isometric view through levels that keep getting harder. You pick one of three character classes, each with its own abilities, and upgrade your weapons with collectables called upgrade cores. It's rated Mature 17+.
Online co-op is where it shines, and the couch is left out
Critics agreed that Alienation is at its best with other people. Game Informer's Matt Miller preferred co-op to solo play and put its multiplayer shooting among the best twin-stick play available. GameSpot's Jason D'Aprile said that "with a full troop online" it was one of the best all-out action multiplayer games in recent memory. Metro's David Jenkins found the co-op "fun no matter what".
The catch is that all of this happens online. There's no local co-op, and several reviewers couldn't understand why. USgamer's Jaz Rignall said it would have been the "perfect game for couch co-op". GamesRadar's Ben Tyrer liked the game but thought it needed a "tense, pad-crushing" couch mode.
If you can count on three friends to join you online, this is a much better game than it is for someone who plays alone.
Too few guns and not enough ammo
The loot side drew the most complaints. IGN's Vince Ingenito wanted more weapons and was disappointed that many of them looked and behaved the same. Devore praised the shooting but still noted that the arsenal stays small, even with upgrades.
Ammo was the other sore spot. Miller found the upgrade system interesting but kept running dry, and he blamed "tediously small ammo clips" for spoiling the fun. In a game that asks you to grind for loot, a small and samey set of weapons hurts more than usual, because the reward for replaying a stage is less exciting than it should be.
Smaller complaints worth knowing
- No pause. D'Aprile was annoyed that you can't pause the game, even in single-player.
- Bland enemies. Jenkins called the creature designs "uninspired", though he thought the graphics held up.
- Forgettable maps. Tyrer said the maps might not stick with you, even though the shooting mechanics and design do.
None of these sink the game on its own. The missing pause hits solo players hardest, and they already get the weaker version of Alienation.
Sources
- Wikipedia: Alienation (video game) en.wikipedia.org
- Wikidata: Q24192183 wikidata.org