Analysis · Among Us

Among Us is sharpest as an Impostor and only as good as your group

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

The best praise and the sharpest complaints

The best thing critics said about Among Us is that it turns an old parlor game into something tense and funny. Alice O'Conner of Rock, Paper, Shotgun called it "Mafia or Werewolf but with minigames", and the PC version holds an 85 out of 100 on Metacritic. The harshest complaints are about how it's delivered. William Antonelli of Insider called the Nintendo Switch version "inferior" to the PC and mobile versions. Tiraxa of Jeuxvideo.com described server bugs that keep some players from joining "in a totally unexplained way".

Both are true. The design earned its praise, while the delivery earned its complaints, depending on where and with whom you play. The critic average of 7.9, computed from 27 critics, sits about where you'd expect from that split.

A simple loop that runs on lying

Four to 15 players share a map, and up to three are secretly made Impostors. Crewmates win by finishing their tasks or voting out every Impostor. Impostors win by killing or ejecting Crewmates until the two sides are even, or by sabotaging a critical system that nobody fixes in time.

Tasks are small minigames and toggles, such as fixing wires or downloading data. Impostors can't do them, only pretend to. What they can do is crawl through vents, kill nearby players and cut the lights so everyone sees less. Any living player can report a body or press the Emergency Meeting button. That's where the real game starts: an argument in text chat or an outside voice app such as Discord, followed by a vote.

As of 2026 there are five maps, from the spaceship The Skeld to the Fungle, a mushroom jungle. Each map has its own way to catch a liar: security cameras on The Skeld, a door log on MIRA HQ and a vitals readout on Polus. A November 2021 update added Engineers, Scientists and the Guardian Angel role. Those roles make the old proofs less certain. Seeing someone use a vent proves much less once Engineers are in the game.

Better as the killer than the crew

Critics agreed on this more than anything else. Elliott Osange of Bonus Stage called the game "silly fun" but said it's more fun "to be an Impostor". Craig Pearson of Rock, Paper, Shotgun found the Impostor role "a lot more fun" and called the Crewmate side "exhausting".

That imbalance matters, because most players are Crewmates in most rounds. Tasks give them something to do and supply evidence, since visual tasks prove a player's identity to anyone watching. Still, they're maintenance chores by design. For the crew, nearly all the fun is in the meetings.

"Who you play with dictates how fun the game is." (Andrew Penney, TheGamer)

Penney's line is the closest thing this game has to a rule. Tiraxa found public games with strangers "less entertaining" than private games with friends. IGN's Leana Hafer wanted some way to punish players who rage-quit when they aren't picked as Impostor or get caught in the middle of a kill.

Which version to pick

Critics found real differences between versions:

  • PC: Osange called it "stable", and it has the highest Metacritic score, 85.
  • Mobile: It's free to play, but Osange called its ads and paid cosmetics "nonsense", since most of those cosmetics are free on PC. He also said Android performance is "a device-by-device situation".
  • Nintendo Switch: It scored 79 on Metacritic. Antonelli liked the touchscreen in handheld mode but found tasks awkward on a gamepad when the console is docked. He also called typing with the joystick "slow", which leaves Switch players at an "immediate disadvantage" in cross-platform games. PJ O'Reilly of Nintendo Life noted that the Switch was missing content found on other platforms, such as skins.

On every platform, Hafer flagged trouble finding rooms that weren't already full. There's also no built-in voice chat, a gap Tiraxa pointed out, so most groups will end up using an outside app anyway. One thing helps newcomers: Jeuxvideo.com praised Freeplay mode, which lets you walk a map alone and learn the rooms before a real match.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet