Amplitude's 2016 return keeps the 2003 formula and stumbles on the songs
Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.
A fan-funded sequel to a 2003 cult favorite
Amplitude is Harmonix going back to its roots. The 2016 game is a sequel to Amplitude (2003), one of the studio's early abstract rhythm games, made long before its plastic-instrument band games. Sony owns the rights to the original and to Frequency, so Harmonix made the new game under license and published it itself.
Fans paid for it. Slant Magazine pointed to how the studio had answered the concerns of the fans "who funded them on Kickstarter". It came out on PlayStation 4 on January 5, 2016, and on PlayStation 3 on April 3, 2016.
It also shares a foundation with Harmonix's biggest work of that period. The studio built a new engine, Forge, for this reboot and used the same engine for Rock Band 4. That makes Amplitude a small, personal project running on the same technology as a big commercial release.
What it kept: the same core, rebuilt
The design brief was simple: keep the original's style of play, then add new songs, modern graphics and support for current PlayStation hardware features. Harmonix didn't try to reinvent the game, and critics noticed.
411Mania said the studio did "a great job" of recapturing the original's body, and called the play easy to pick up even for people who hadn't touched the first game in years. The Escapist called it an exciting mix of rhythm action and electronica that "does well by its predecessors". The Daily Telegraph described the core as "timeless".
Being this faithful has a cost. If the 2003 game never clicked for you, little here is built to change your mind.
What it added: team play and a nod to FreQuency
Most of the changes are about who plays and how the track looks.
- Team play. Two teams play through one song, either 2-on-2 or 3-on-1, mixing cooperation and competition. Nobody fails out, and the mode adjusts for each player's difficulty level. Harmonix's Pete Maguire suggested it, and it went in late in development.
- FreQuency mode. The original's nearly flat track can be switched to the tunnel layout from Frequency, an option clearly aimed at longtime fans.
Team play is the biggest change to how the game works, since it turns a solo score chase into something a living room can share. The FreQuency mode is more of a tribute than a new idea.
Where critics split: the music and the gated songs
Metacritic rated the PS4 version "average", one point short of generally favorable. The aggregate was 72/100 from 50 reviews, and the critic average, calculated from critic scores, is 7.2. Individual reviews ranged widely.
- The Digital Fix, eight out of ten: a "unique concept album" that tests both mind and hands.
- Slant Magazine, four stars out of five: so clearly a labor of love that it's hard to criticize.
- The Escapist, three-and-a-half stars out of five: wanted more "star power" in the soundtrack and called the requirements for opening up new songs a ridiculous way to pad the length.
- 411Mania, seven out of ten: the soundtrack, which it called the game's soul, may send players elsewhere.
- The Daily Telegraph, three stars out of five: praised its "thumping heart and soul".
- National Post, six out of ten: compared it to an album from a favorite band that you try hard to love and then rarely play.
The pattern is clear. Critics who liked it praised its feel and its devotion to the original. Critics who marked it down rarely faulted the play. They faulted the songs, and in a rhythm game, the songs are most of what you get.
Sources
- Wikipedia: Amplitude (2016 video game) en.wikipedia.org
- Wikidata: Q102218017 wikidata.org