Animal Crossing's Wii U board game hides its charm behind amiibo scanning
Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.
A board game you play by tapping toys
Each turn of amiibo Festival plays like a virtual board game in the style of the Mario Party series, with Animal Crossing's cast in place of Mario's. The difference is in your hands. The game generally needs amiibo figures to play, so you take part by placing a toy on the Wii U controller instead of just pressing buttons. Isabelle, K.K. Slider, Tom Nook and Mabel are among the playable characters. All four are from the series' set of characters that got amiibo figures across three waves.
Critics thought this setup was the core problem. IGN called the amiibo integration "cumbersome" and "hard to play with," and said the pace was slow enough to call it a "snooze fest." Nintendo World Report pointed to "boring, repetitive gameplay." When every action needs a scan, a slow board game gets slower still.
The minigames are built around amiibo cards
Outside the main board, the game has eight minigames, each opened by scanning Animal Crossing amiibo cards. These are where the design gets the most out of the scanner, because the cards themselves are the controls:
- Resetti Bop is a single-player game based on Whac-A-Mole. Mechanical Mr. Resetti heads show rock, paper or scissors, and you scan the card for the winning move.
- Acorn Chase uses three cards as left, right and forward. You collect acorns while a lawnmower with Mr. Resetti's head creeps toward you. The directions stay fixed no matter which way your character faces.
- Mystery Campers is a logic puzzle. Four of six characters hide in tents, and you have under ten tries to place them, with clues about how many picks are correct or close.
- Fruit Path is for two players. Each picks three cards, and the die printed on a card's corner decides how far that character moves to collect fruit and avoid pitfalls.
- Balloon Island supports one to four players. You lift a card off the scanner to drop a character onto balloons, and you earn a score multiplier for landing on the island.
On paper, the card-as-controller idea is clever, and Mystery Campers has a real puzzle in it. The catch is the price of entry: you can only reach this content if you own the cards.
Slow rewards and a shopping list
Progress runs through a "Happy Points" system. Points turn into Happy Tickets, which buy outfits, and an amiibo figure can store both your outfit and your point total. If you own Animal Crossing: Happy Home Designer, houses you designed there can also be placed in amiibo Festival.
Both links make sense for fans, but they also mean the game keeps pointing you at things you'd have to buy. Critics noticed. Nintendo World Report said it seemed to take "an hour to get anything good," and GamesBeat gave it 3.3 out of 10, calling it a "blatant attempt" to sell more amiibo.
A game that needs extra figures and extra cards to show you its best parts is asking for more than its box price.
Where the critics gave it credit
The reviews weren't all negative. Critics described the game as "undoubtedly charming" and relaxing, and agreed it works best with friends on the couch. That fits the series: the characters and the gentle mood come through even when the pace drags. In Japan, Famitsu's four critics gave it a combined 32 out of 40, far warmer than IGN, Nintendo World Report or GamesBeat.
Players weren't convinced either. The game sold just 20,303 copies in its first week in Japan, and it stands as the clearest misstep in a series whose earlier entries reviewed well. The critic average of 4.8 out of 10, worked out from critic aggregates, lands about where IGN's 5 and Nintendo World Report's 4.5 did.
It's rated Everyone and only came out on Wii U, starting November 13, 2015, in North America. If you already own a drawer full of Animal Crossing amiibo, it gives them something to do. If you don't, the main series is a far better place to spend time with these characters.
Sources
- Wikipedia: Animal Crossing: Amiibo Festival en.wikipedia.org
- Wikidata: Q20128820 wikidata.org