Arceus turns catching Pokémon into the whole game, and critics mostly cheered
Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.
Built for fans who wanted to catch more and grind less
Arceus is for players who know the mainline Pokémon games and want something different from them. It keeps the core ideas: a Pokédex to fill, turn-based battles, and a choice of three starters (Rowlet, Cyndaquil and Oshawott, the first time a mainline game has offered starters from different regions together). Then it moves the center of the game outdoors.
It's set long before Pokémon Diamond and Pearl, as a prequel. The map is split into five large areas, each with its own biome. You arrive at a camp, fast travel between camps in the same area, and head out on foot or on rideable Pokémon that can swim, climb cliffs or fly. This isn't one continuous open world. Because of the hub-and-areas layout, reviewers compared it to the Monster Hunter series, and others pointed to The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild for both its play and its art style.
For a series fan who has felt each new entry was a repeat of the last, that structure is the point. For players who mainly want competitive battles, it's a weaker fit, because the game drops the head-to-head battles those players come for.
Where it delivers: the catch is fast and the world reacts
Catching is the clearest win. You can throw a ball at a wild Pokémon without starting a battle, though some have to be fought first. Polygon's Ryan Gilliam, who otherwise had problems with the battle system, called grabbing a Pokémon while exploring "easy and fluid". Nintendo Life's Jordan Middler called the catching "addictive" and the exploration "rewarding", and went as far as ranking it among the greatest Pokémon games ever made.
The wild Pokémon also behave like animals rather than random encounters. Some run from you, some attack, and some have their own habits. For the first time in the series, they can hurt the player character; take enough damage and you black out and wake up back at camp. Larger, tougher "Alpha" Pokémon roam the areas too. Eurogamer's Chris Tapsell singled out the animation, describing creatures that hop, roll, lumber and waddle with real personality.
Critics also liked how the pieces connect. Ars Technica's Andrew Cunningham noted that when a fight ends you go straight back to exploring, with no pause for level-ups or move learning. Dot Esports' Jessica Scharnagle said many tedious, forced activities from earlier games were trimmed or cut. The Verge's Andrew Webster called it the "biggest overhaul" since the series began, and The Guardian's Tom Regan said everything felt fresh.
- Battles let you trade attack damage for extra turns, or the reverse.
- Boss fights have you dodge and strike in real time, with turn-based battles used to stun the boss.
- Side quests from townsfolk add to Pokédex progress alongside catching and battling.
Where it falls short: looks, performance and battles
The complaints were consistent. The Guardian praised the exploration but judged the visuals poorly against Breath of the Wild and Xenoblade Chronicles 2. Ars Technica disliked the graphical style outright. Dot Esports criticized the performance. If a Switch game's image quality matters to you, that's the trade you're making here.
Battling is the other weak spot. Polygon criticized the battle system even while enjoying everything around it. For anyone who plays Pokémon to battle other people, there's a bigger issue: Arceus has no multiplayer battles, unlike earlier entries. Online trading is still there.
The roster is also smaller than some fans expect. The game launched with 242 Pokémon, including 7 new species and 17 new forms of existing ones. Ars Technica counted the lack of new Pokémon against it.
The more you care about exploring and catching, the better this game looks. The more you care about battling or graphics, the worse.
How it landed
Critics landed on the positive side. Aggregate scores sit between 82 and 86 out of 100, and 85% of counted critics recommended it. It was nominated for Best RPG at The Game Awards 2022 and for Game of the Year by several outlets, including Polygon and The Washington Post. The praise went to the new direction, and the criticism went to execution, not to the idea.
Sources
- Wikipedia: Pokémon Legends: Arceus en.wikipedia.org
- Wikidata: Q105688771 wikidata.org