Analysis · Batman: Arkham City

Arkham City turns a walled-off Gotham slum into a playground for Batman

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

The idea is being the world's greatest detective, on patrol

Most critics came back to the same point. Arkham City is less about a plot than about how it feels to be Batman in a city that's his to roam. Eurogamer's Christian Donlan said the traversal tools made it "hard not to feel like the world's greatest detective, on patrol", and IGN's Greg Miller listed "the feeling of being the Dark Knight" among the things that stood out most.

The design backs that up. Arkham City is a super-prison built around the decaying slums of Gotham City, and the whole of it is open from the start. Batman glides on his cape, diving to gain speed and swooping up to stretch a flight, and he pulls himself onto high ledges with the grapnel gun. Detective Vision highlights enemies, clues and collectibles, and it also handles forensic work such as tracing a sniper round back to where it was fired from.

The best way to judge each part of the game is to ask whether it adds to that feeling. Most of it does.

Combat makes you read a crowd before you swing

The Freeflow combat system comes back from Batman: Arkham Asylum with more to do. Batman can counter several blows at once, catch thrown objects, attack from the air and chain strikes together, and many of his gadgets now work mid-fight.

What makes it feel like Batman rather than a brawler is that enemies need different answers:

  • Thugs with stun batons can only be hit from behind.
  • Shield carriers have to be disarmed with aerial attacks.
  • Enemies in body armor need a fast run of strikes before they take damage.
  • Larger enemies need stuns and combos, and can be turned against their allies.

Guns hurt far more than bats and pipes, so armed rooms push you toward stealth: gadgets, silent movement and takedowns from cover. The Daily Telegraph's Tom Hoggins praised the "show-stopping brutality" of the fights and the sense of progress as Batman's abilities open up. Experience points buy upgrades across four areas (the Batsuit, gadgets, combat and stealth), with about 15 options in each.

The story is where the idea runs thin

The plot, written by Paul Dini with Paul Crocker and Sefton Hill, has Bruce Wayne locked inside Arkham City while he works out what its warden, Hugo Strange, is planning. Critics liked how it opened and how it ended. They were less sure about the middle.

Joystiq's Griffin McElroy was the sharpest critic here. He called the story a string of excuses to meet villains who were "one-dimensional punching [bags]", and found the dialogue clichéd. He also found the Riddler challenges "frustrating" when you don't yet have the item a puzzle needs. The Guardian's Nick Cowen saw it the other way, praising how satisfying the Riddler missions were and how much side content the city holds.

Donlan's main complaint was that the sequel lacked the "surprise" of Arkham Asylum, even though he thought the bosses, animation and range of activities had all improved.

The Catwoman sections drew wide praise as a change of pace, lighter and quicker than Batman's heavy hitting. Hoggins called them a "delight" but wished there were more. Miller also liked the option to replay the game with the abilities you've already earned against tougher enemies.

Which version to pick, and what to skip

On Metacritic, the PlayStation 3 version averaged 96/100, the Xbox 360 version 94 and the PC version 91. All three sit near the top of their year, so pick whichever platform you have.

The Wii U release, Batman: Arkham City Armored Edition, is the exception at 85. Eurogamer's Richard Leadbetter pointed to rough visuals and an uneven frame rate. EGM's Ray Carsillo called it the "clearly inferior version", citing glitches and gimmicks, and said its optional B.A.T. system made some fights too easy. Some critics liked its persistent map and touch-screen menus, so reviews of it were split, but none of the defenses make it the version to choose today.

The Harley Quinn's Revenge add-on also split critics. Miller gave it 9 out of 10. Donlan gave it 7 and said it offered nothing the main game didn't, and Kotaku's Stephen Totilo felt it was built from leftover material and left plot threads hanging. Treat it as optional.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet