Arkham Knight gives Batman a tank, and critics mostly forgave him for it
Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.
The fourth main game, and a direct follow-up to Arkham City
Batman: Arkham Knight came out on June 23, 2015. It is the fourth main installment in the Batman: Arkham series. It follows the 2013 game Arkham Origins in release order, but its story picks up from Rocksteady Studios' own Batman: Arkham City (2011), nine months after that game ends.
The setup is simple. Scarecrow attacks Gotham City and forces a citywide evacuation. With help from a masked newcomer called the Arkham Knight, he tries to unite the city's criminals to destroy Batman for good. The Toronto Sun's Steve Tilley read it as a satisfying, large-scale conclusion to Rocksteady's Arkham games. That fits: much of what's here builds on what the studio made before.
What carried over from the earlier games
Fans of the series will recognize most of the toolkit. The grapnel gun, line launcher, batarangs, Detective Vision and the Remote Hacking Device all return. Combat still runs on the Freeflow system of strikes, counters and dodges, chained so Batman keeps moving between enemies.
The older tools got upgrades rather than replacements:
- The Disruptor is now a rifle that can disable enemy guns and drone turrets, rig weapon crates to shock anyone who grabs them, and tag vehicles.
- The remote-controlled batarang carries a scanner to read the area around it.
- Gliding is faster and lasts longer, and the grapnel can be fired twice in the air to chain moves together.
IGN's Dan Stapleton called the combat and predator systems an overall improvement. Game Informer's Andrew Reiner felt the fights were somewhat easier than in earlier games.
What changed: a whole city, a car and a second hero
The biggest shift is scale. Gotham is open from the start, and you can travel anywhere inside its borders. Critics praised the city's detail almost across the board. Reiner called it "a beautifully realized playground for Batman" and pointed to its distinct boroughs.
The new systems go further than a bigger map. Dual Play lets you switch control to Robin, Nightwing or Catwoman during certain fights, and your combo score carries over between characters. GamesTM called it the best part of the game, and GameSpot's Kevin VanOrd liked it too. A Voice Synthesizer lets Batman imitate Harley Quinn or the Arkham Knight to lure thugs into traps.
Enemies also got smarter. Medics shield allies in electric fields and revive downed ones. Brutes have to be stunned first. Thugs lay landmines, fly drones, block vents once they find Batman in them, and can track him if he leans on Detective Vision too long.
The Batmobile is where reviewers split
The car is the change people argued about. As transport, it was mostly liked: Reiner said it "packs a satisfying punch," and VanOrd called the driving "slick and satisfying." Its Battle Mode, which turns it into a tank, was another story.
Stapleton at IGN called Battle Mode "about as un-Batman an activity" as he could picture, though he still found the tank fights fun.
Eurogamer's Dan Whitehead named it one of the weaker parts. GamesRadar's Sam Roberts called some of the car's additions a "misfire." VanOrd went the other way and called Battle Mode a "delight," but he flagged the clash between Batman's no-kill rule and a vehicle built for wrecking things.
The Riddler drew similar splits. GamesTM liked how his challenges tied into Dual Play. Destructoid's Chris Carter found many of them "tedious" and disliked needing them for the full ending, and Roberts called the racetracks "beyond silly."
A story people either loved or saw coming
Reiner called the game a "narrative juggernaut" with "the mother of all plot twists," and VideoGamer.com's Simon Miller called it "the best Batman game ever made." Others were cooler. VanOrd found the themes and repeated metaphors "ham-fisted," and Roberts pointed to hammy dialogue and an unconvincing pair of main villains.
The Arkham Knight's identity got the most pushback. Stapleton and Roberts both felt it had been sold as an original character when it wasn't, and that informed Batman fans could guess the twist early. Reiner and Miller were happy with the reveal.
One practical note: the PC version drew "mixed or average" reviews at launch, while the PlayStation 4 and Xbox One versions were rated "generally favorable." Later aggregates, including a score of 83% from 120 reviews in February 2025, still put it well above average.
Sources
- Wikipedia: Batman: Arkham Knight en.wikipedia.org
- Wikidata: Q15891648 wikidata.org