Analysis · Batman: Arkham Origins

Arkham Origins gives the Joker his best scenes and Gotham too much space

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

The Joker carries it while the series stands still

Critics liked the Joker best in Batman: Arkham Origins. Their biggest complaint was that the series stopped moving forward. Polygon said the story showed a new side of a villain the earlier Arkham games had already leaned on, and GameSpot called it surprising in how it explored the bond, and the likeness, between Batman and the Joker. That same GameSpot review faulted the game for copying Arkham City without moving the series forward, and called its larger map "bigger just for the sake of being bigger".

That split explains the scores. Aggregate scores land between 70 and 76 out of 100 depending on platform. The PlayStation 3 version is the only one rated "generally favorable". The critic average, computed from those critic aggregates, is 7.3. Some reviewers put the game level with Arkham City. More called it routine.

A younger Batman and a story that loses its thread

The game is set on Christmas Eve, eight years before Batman: Arkham Asylum, and follows a younger, rougher Batman. Crime lord Black Mask puts a bounty on him, and eight assassins come to Gotham City to collect it. The police are hunting him too, and the Joker and Anarky use the chaos for their own plans.

Critics liked how the story handles beginnings: how Batman's ties to his allies and enemies start, and whether his presence makes Gotham's crime worse. EGM said that when the story works, it is worthy of any Batman film, TV show or comic book. The complaint is about how it hangs together. The assassin plot that opens the game is largely forgotten by the end.

The voice cast drew praise. Troy Baker's Joker was called a worthy replacement for Mark Hamill, though some critics felt his take copied Hamill's too closely. The writers, Dooma Wendschuh, Corey May and Ryan Galletta, were nominated by the Writers Guild of America. JB Blanc won a BTVA award for his Bane.

Boss fights improved, but the gadgets make combat too easy

Boss battles are the one area where critics agreed the game beats its predecessors. These are multiphase fights, each with its own small story, and reviewers valued their variety and unpredictability even when not every one worked. Fights against lesser-known comic characters were judged weaker than those against famous ones.

Elsewhere the reviews turn mixed:

  • Shock Gloves give Batman unblockable hits that drop most enemies at once, which critics said made fights too easy and tactics pointless.
  • Bigger, tougher crowds, including enemies who block and counter Batman's attacks and Venom-infused henchmen whose attacks can't be countered, made long fights feel punishing and repetitive rather than challenging.
  • The Remote Claw can take out several enemies in a stealth section without Batman leaving his starting spot.
  • The combat rating tracker was distracting screen clutter to Kotaku and positive reinforcement to GameFront.

Stealth works much as it did in earlier games, so the ways to win stay the same, and reviewers called it rote. Joystiq noted the game leans on combat over stealth. Detective Mode split critics. Kotaku and GameSpot said it comes down to walking to the next highlighted clue, while Game Informer found the crime scenes complicated and good at showing how Batman thinks.

A larger Gotham with less reason to explore it

The open city is packed with side missions and distractions, and some reviewers found its size engrossing. Others didn't. Joystiq called the city unattractive, saying the bigger map made the commute longer but no more fun. Some areas block grappling, which slows or stops travel. The Batwing fast travel only opens up after Batman disables enemy towers, and some towers need gear that comes later. Polygon found the world more linear than before, with few reasons to go back to old areas with new gadgets except to hunt collectibles. Kotaku called the side quests "busy work". Some new gadgets just repeat old ones: the glue grenade does the same job as Arkham City's ice grenades.

The multiplayer mode fared worst. Polygon called it one of the least necessary multiplayer add-ons to a single-player series. GameSpot said poor gun accuracy and clumsy movement made the thugs feel weak and inept, while the heroes felt underpowered. A few reviewers found it fun and hectic but too shallow to hold interest.

The Cold, Cold Heart DLC got a warmer reception. Reviewers found it better paced and more focused than the main game, though it loses focus near the end. GameSpot liked its mix of combat, stealth and detective work and its new enemies with ice guns.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet