Analysis · Arms

Arms rewards the players who stick with its stretchy, slow-motion boxing

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

The same depth earned praise and complaints

The sharpest split among critics wasn't about whether Arms works. It was about how much it asks of you. Brandon Graeber at IGN praised the game's complexity and called it addictive. Kallie Plagge at GameSpot liked the character roster but criticized the steep learning curve. Both reviewers were describing the same system and reached opposite conclusions about it.

That split is the most useful thing to know before you buy. Arms looks like a party game, with bright characters and springy, cartoon fists. Underneath, it plays like a fighter that expects you to learn matchups, timing and loadouts. Whether that excites you or tires you out decides how you'll feel about it.

Every punch is a choice you made before the round

Fighters attack from range with extendable arms. You can punch, throw, block and dodge, and you steer each arm separately. You can do that with the Joy-Con motion controls or with standard buttons on a controller such as the Pro Controller.

The complexity IGN liked comes from the layers stacked on that base:

  • Each fighter starts with three unique Arms, and you pick the left and right independently.
  • Arms differ in weight and elemental effect, which changes how they hit and what they beat.
  • Charging an attack briefly boosts its damage and triggers its elemental effect.
  • A full attack meter lets you fire a high-damage rush attack.
  • Each fighter has unique attributes in combat on top of their Arms.

Other fighters' Arms can be unlocked in the Get Arms mode, so the loadout options keep growing the longer you play. That's a reward for players who stay, and it's also why GameSpot found the climb steep. There's a lot to absorb before matches stop feeling random.

A thin launch that later updates filled in

IGN's other complaint was a lack of content at launch. The game shipped with ten playable fighters, and five more arrived through post-release updates, so anyone buying now gets the full roster.

The modes are what they are. Grand Prix is a run of 10 matches against computer-controlled fighters for a championship belt. Beyond that there's Versus, plus Battle modes built on volleyball, basketball, target breaking and survival. Two-on-two matches tether teammates together, and free-for-alls take three or four players.

Online is where the game is meant to live: party lobbies hold up to 20 players, and ranked play is one-on-one. The game has built a small but dedicated esports scene across multiple regions. For a fighter, that kind of following says more about the depth than any feature list.

Who the split points to

Critics kept reaching for other Nintendo games to explain Arms. It's been compared to the boxing minigame from Wii Sports. Michael McWhertor at Polygon called the concept creative, likened it to Nintendo's classic boxing series, and suggested it could become Nintendo's next big franchise. Edge went further:

"Arms is to the fighting game what Splatoon is to the online shooter or Mario Kart to the driving game." (Edge)

That comparison explains the split better than the scores do. Splatoon and Mario Kart are easy to start and have a high ceiling. Arms has the ceiling, but critics like GameSpot found the start harder than the look suggests.

If you enjoy labbing loadouts and grinding ranked matches, the complexity IGN praised is the whole point, and the roster is now complete. If you mostly want a few rounds with friends on the couch, the Battle modes help, but expect a learning curve before the fights feel fair. And if you mostly play alone, a 10-match Grand Prix and some side modes won't hold you for long.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet