Analysis · Assassin's Creed Odyssey

Assassin's Creed Odyssey trades the hidden blade for a war in ancient Greece

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

Strong scores on one side, demanding design on the other

Critics scored Assassin's Creed Odyssey well, and they did it consistently. One aggregate of 32 reviews gives it 87/100 on every version it tracked, from PlayStation 4 and Xbox One through PlayStation 5 and Xbox Series X and Series S. A larger pool of 166 reviews lands at 84/100, and a third aggregate of 27 reviews sits at 82/100. That's the strongest praise on record: high marks on every platform.

The record doesn't include a specific complaint from any critic, so the weak spots worth weighing come from how the game is built. Odyssey puts combat and exploration ahead of stealth, in a series named after assassins. Every area also has a recommended level, and a player who wanders in too early can be easily overpowered. Most of what follows comes back to those two choices.

Greece is the main event

The game is set during the Peloponnesian War between Athens and Sparta, from 431 to 422 BCE, and it tells a mythological version of that history. You can cross a large open world on foot, on horseback or by boat. Naval combat, carried over from earlier games in the series, plays a big part.

The map is packed with things to do:

  • side missions from the people you meet
  • fortresses and camps to clear
  • tombs and shipwrecks to explore, and treasure to find
  • fights in a gladiator arena
  • bounties and contracts with time limits

Odyssey also adds something new to the series. In Guided mode, waypoints show you where to go. In Exploration mode, the people you meet give you short clues and you find the place yourself. Exploration mode suits the setting better, because it makes you read the land instead of following a marker.

The war and the mercenaries keep the map moving

Athens and Sparta each control parts of Greece, and you can weaken a region's ruling side by killing its leader, defeating its soldiers, burning its war supplies or looting its treasury. Once a region is weak enough, a conquest battle opens up, and you can fight for either the attackers or the defenders. Siding with the attackers is harder but pays out more, and winning brings loot, gear and experience.

Crime has a cost too. Steal something or hurt a bystander in public and a bounty goes on your head, and mercenaries come to hunt you down. You can fight them, pay off the bounty or kill whoever posted it. Having three ways out gives these interruptions some depth, though they can still pull you away from whatever you were doing.

A role-playing game first, an Assassin's Creed game second

At the start, you pick one of two heroes, Alexios or Kassandra. Both are Greek mercenaries descended from the Spartan king Leonidas I. The main story follows them as they try to bring their family back together and take down the Cult of Kosmos, while other quest lines pit them against mythical creatures from Atlantis and more cultists. In the modern day, Layla Hassan relives the mercenary's memories through the Animus to track down a powerful artifact.

Conversations come with dialogue choices, including romance with some characters. Big decisions at key points in the story change where it goes and lead to several different endings. This is where Odyssey is furthest from the early games in the series, and it explains why critics could score it so well even with stealth pushed into the background.

The catch is the level system. Enemies scale to your level, but each region still has a recommended level, so going off the main path early can mean a beating instead of a discovery. If you liked the quick assassinations of older entries, you'll probably notice that more than someone who comes to it for the role-playing. The game is rated Mature 17+.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet