Analysis · Astral Chain

Astral Chain's silent hero split critics, but its chained Legions did not

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

The silent lead is where critics split

Critics disagreed most about the person you play, not about the combat. At the start, you pick one of two twin detectives in the Neuron task force. The one you pick stays silent for the rest of the game, while the other twin is fully voiced. Francesco De Meo of Wccftech said this choice "doesn't really work well" for the story, since the same character has a voice when you don't pick them. Game Informer and GameSpot made the same complaint.

Many of those same critics liked the people around that silent lead. Reviewers praised the side characters and the world of the Ark, the city where the game is set. Chris Plante of Polygon went furthest, calling it "a deeply human game" about people trying to do good in small, everyday ways, and named it Nintendo's best new series since Splatoon.

That tells you what kind of story this is. If you want a strong lead whose arc carries the plot, expect a gap at the center. If you care more about a place and its people, critics found plenty to like.

Light combos, a deep Legion toolkit

The combat drew little disagreement. You fight alongside a Legion, a creature tied to you by the chain the game is named after. It attacks on its own while you fight, and you can steer it with the right stick to set up combos. You start with the Sword Legion and capture four more over the course of the game:

  • Sword: fast blade attacks that cut circuits and interrupt enemies.
  • Arrow: you can aim it yourself to hit weak points and faraway switches.
  • Arm: heavy punches that move large objects, and armor that lets you hover over dangerous ground.
  • Axe: a shield that breaks objects and enemy shields.
  • Beast: a K9 that tracks scents, digs up hidden items and can be ridden.

You can switch Legions at any point in a fight. The chain also has its own uses: wrap it around enemies to bind them, or stretch it in the path of a charging enemy to trip them up. Each Legion has a health meter that drains while it's out and refills while it rests, so knowing when to pull it back matters as much as knowing when to send it in.

Steven Petite of IGN put the trade-off clearly: the game "lacks a deep combo system" but makes up for it with its roster of Legions. Players who want long memorized combo strings may find that a real loss. Players who enjoy managing two fighters at once get more to work with than in a typical brawler.

A slow start and plenty of detective work

Destructoid's Chris Carter said the game starts a little slowly. He was "completely sold" once customization opened up, and he praised the bosses and the variety of enemies. Expect the first few hours to feel more like a tutorial than the rest.

A good share of the game isn't combat at all. You question people, examine evidence and solve logic puzzles to build each case. Then you go into the Astral Plane, a dangerous dimension that plays like a dungeon, with tricky terrain, puzzles and fights. Polygon singled out the small side jobs where you help residents of the Ark. Players who only want to fight may find these slow, but they give the game much of its warmth.

What the numbers add up to

OpenCritic found that 95% of critics recommended the game, and an aggregate of 109 reviews landed at 87/100. The critic average, worked out from those critic aggregates, is 8.6 out of 10. Eurogamer's Martin Robinson gave it an "Essential" rating and called it PlatinumGames' best game so far.

Metacritic users review-bombed the game at launch, mostly because it was a Switch exclusive. Metacritic later removed those reviews. Don't let user scores from that period put you off.

The game also came 10th for Game of the Year at the 2019 Edge Awards. It's rated Teen.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet