Analysis · Astroneer

Astroneer swaps hunger and thirst for an oxygen leash, and it mostly works

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

The terrain tool is the whole game, and it's a good one

Most of Astroneer happens at the end of the Terrain Tool. You point it at the ground and the ground gives way. Whatever was buried there comes back as neat stacks that snap into slots on your backpack: resin, compound, quartz, lithium, ammonium and, if you're lucky, astronium. The same tool reshapes the land, so a hill in your way becomes a ramp and a cliff face becomes a tunnel. Critics liked this. Nintendo Life singled out the terrain tool by name, and Shacknews praised the crafting and base building it feeds.

Your backpack is both your inventory and your on-screen display. It has two quick-use slots, eight storage slots, a basic 3D printer, a power reserve shown as yellow segments and an oxygen bar. You don't escape into menus. Everything you carry is on your back, and so is the meter that can end your trip.

Oxygen is the leash, and the leash is the design

Survival here means breathing and nothing else. There's no hunger or thirst, and USgamer placed the game on "the soft side of the survival spectrum" as a compliment. You refill from portable oxygenators, from snail creatures, or by staying near tethers. You chain tethers out from a base or another oxygen source to push farther from home. Since the full release, you also need an oxygenator connected to a shelter or platform to extend that reach.

GameSpot named oxygen tethering as a highlight, and it's easy to see why. Every trip outward leaves a visible line back to safety. Exploring becomes a matter of planning a route rather than racing a timer.

No food, no water. Your air supply and a trail of tethers are all that stand between a short scouting run and a long walk home.

A wide crafting tree on planets that run thin

The game's structure comes from research. You collect "bytes" and spend them in the Research Catalog to add new blueprints. Then you build up from basic resin and compound to smelters, chemistry labs, atmospheric condensers, generators, turbines, solar panels, rovers, tractors and spacecraft. The long-term goal is to travel between planets and activate their cores, which often earns you a new suit or visor. Planets are procedurally generated, apart from some resources that belong to specific planets.

This is where critics found the limits. USgamer and GameSpot both said each planet lacks interesting things to find, and GameSpot added that inventory management gets cumbersome. A crafting tree this wide needs places worth driving a buggy to. Reviewers felt the worlds didn't always provide them.

Lovely to look at, rough around the edges

The presentation drew the most consistent praise. GameSpot applauded the art direction and wide open spaces. Shacknews gave the game eight out of ten for its atmosphere, setting and looks, and also called out co-op play. Co-op suits a game this slow, since digging and laying tether lines go better with company.

The technical side drew the most consistent complaints. Shacknews noted minor issues and GameSpot flagged technical problems. Nintendo Life's review of the Switch port listed a choppy framerate, janky physics and a poor camera and controls. Even so, it praised how well the game suited the console and how well the developer kept supporting it.

Scores reflect the split. Metacritic rated the Windows and Xbox One versions mixed or average and the Switch version generally favorable. Aggregate scores have ranged from 75/100 across 26 reviews in January 2022 to 58% across 27 reviews in October 2024. Players have been less divided: by March 2022, System Era Softworks reported over 3,740,000 units sold and more than 8 million players.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet