Analysis · Atomic Heart

Atomic Heart builds a robot utopia, then hands you the wreckage to fight with

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

A robot utopia built to fall apart

Atomic Heart rests on one picture: a Soviet state that builds the world's best robots, hands them every menial job and promises its citizens that something even greater is about to happen. Then the robots turn on the people they serve. Kevin Purdy of Ars Technica described a world of "astounding promises" that the game takes apart by exposing hypocrisy, ego-driven leaders and the damage done to ordinary lives.

Critics mostly read it as political satire aimed at authoritarianism, artificial intelligence and communism. Ed Power of The Daily Telegraph called it a "paradise lost". He saw the Politburo and Sechenov at the center of the conflict, with Sechenov cast as a power-hungry madman who poisoned the Communist dream. Renata Price of Vice News wrote that calling it a straight-up celebration of the Soviet Union would be a misrepresentation. Even the KGB, the protagonist's former employer, aren't the good guys.

It's a strong premise. The fair test is whether each part of the game serves it.

The enemies are the promise, broken

On this count, the game passes. Most enemies are robots, the same machines the utopia was built on. The other main type, mutants, are human corpses brought back by genetically engineered plant-like organisms called sprouts. The game's world goes wrong in exactly the way its premise promised.

The tools for fighting back are broad. There are conventional firearms, energy weapons and melee weapons. There's also the Polymer Glove, which grants telekinesis, freezing, a shield, electricity and other powers that combine with both melee and ranged attacks. Cartridges add elemental effects to any weapon and can be looted or crafted.

Critics had trouble with how the fighting felt. PC Gamer saw BioShock as the game's main influence but judged its combat and progression system inferior to it. Polygon also felt it never eclipsed BioShock on gameplay. The theme comes through clearly in who you fight. It comes through less clearly in how fights play out.

Scavenging turns the utopia into your armory

The crafting system is where the idea and the mechanics fit best. Ammo is scarce, so the game pushes you to:

  • pull metal parts off defeated robots;
  • strip parts from household appliances;
  • assemble weapons from those parts;
  • fall back on rechargeable energy guns when bullets run out.

The comforts of the robot paradise literally become your weapons. Between fights, cars help you cross some large open areas. Puzzles appear in the main campaign and in the optional side areas called Polygons, or Testing Grounds. Quick-time events also come up along the way.

Where the satire loses the thread

IGN called the game "deeply ambitious, highly imaginative, and consistently impressive", then faulted its writing and the "tedious" stretches, fetch quests in particular. PC Gamer called it "one of the oddest" AAA games and had mixed feelings about the story and characters. Polygon thought it tried to tackle too many themes at once.

A big idea carries a game only as far as its quests and dialogue let it.

That is the core tension. Critics broadly agreed the premise is sharp. They disagreed on whether the moment-to-moment writing and errands live up to it.

PC reviewed best, and a patch eased the grind

On Metacritic, the PS5 and Xbox Series X/S versions received "mixed or average" reviews, while the PC version was rated "generally favorable". The critic average, calculated from those critic aggregates, is 7.4 out of 10.

A June 2024 patch added accessibility settings that address some of the friction critics described. They include automatic puzzle solving, a colorblind mode, automatic quick-time events and auto-heal. The game is rated Mature 17+ and PEGI 18.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet