Attila turns Rome II's map into a fight to keep a dying empire alive
Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.
Made for strategy players who like a losing position
Total War: Attila is for players who already enjoy the series' mix of turn-based empire building and real-time battles, and who want a campaign that pushes back. It's the ninth standalone game in the Total War series, released on February 17, 2015 for Windows, macOS and Linux. Its setting is the start of the Dark Ages, when the Huns pushed whole peoples west into Roman land.
Comfort isn't on offer. The game is built around survival, and critics who liked it mostly liked it for that reason. Players who want a steady climb to a world empire will find a lot less to enjoy.
Playing as Rome means starting big and shrinking fast
The campaign opens in 395 AD, after the emperor's death split the empire between his two sons: Honorius in the West and Arcadius in the East. The two halves play very differently.
- The Western Roman Empire starts with huge territory, little money and an army too thin to cover it. Waves of displaced peoples cross its borders, and the campaign quickly becomes a question of what to give up.
- The Eastern Roman Empire is the rich half, with Constantinople as its trade hub. It still faces an early Visigoth assault on the capital itself, and it has to keep watching its eastern border.
The map runs from Bactria to Lusitania and from Caledonia to Garamantia in the Sahara. It's about the size of Rome II's map, but it reaches further into modern-day Russia, which puts the nomadic Huns closer to the center of the action. Provinces group three regions that can each be taken on their own. Unlike Rome II, small settlements can eventually be walled, which makes defending them a real choice.
Where it delivers: battles, sieges and a period that fits
The strongest praise went to the fighting. IGN's TJ Hafer called siege battles and the new army types highlights, saying the pacing of real-time battles "adds an extra layer" to the choice of army composition. GamesRadar's Atlas Burke called the tactical battles outstanding. Even Destructoid's Greg Tito, the most negative of the major reviews at 6.5/10, liked the battle improvements.
The setting won people over too. PC Gamer's Dan Griliopoulos, who gave it 83/100, said the game reflected the era accurately and singled out its music, animation and sound. He also liked the new family system, which adds complexity to running a faction. GamesRadar praised the option to turn settlements into armies, which suits a campaign where peoples are on the move.
Several critics read Attila as a direct answer to complaints about Rome II. GamesRadar called its additions "direct responses" to that backlash, and IGN said it was a refinement rather than a glorified expansion pack.
Where it falls short: politics, diplomacy and polish
The campaign layer took more criticism than the battlefield. IGN found internal politics and diplomacy hard to read and frustrating. Destructoid criticized the changes to the political system along with trade and diplomacy, and wondered whether a setting about a falling empire was a good fit for a sequel at all.
Critics also disagreed about the AI. IGN and GamesRadar both said it had improved, yet IGN still called it occasionally nonsensical, and PC Gamer listed AI problems among its complaints.
Technical issues showed up across reviews. PC Gamer cited frame rate trouble, bugs and laggy multiplayer chat, and said the bugs so close to release were worrying. GamesRadar mentioned long end-of-turn waits and unbalanced units. PC Gamer also flagged the extreme difficulty, which will suit some players and push others away. At launch, IGN noted, the Celtic factions weren't playable and lacked their own unit roster.
Sources
- Wikipedia: Total War: Attila en.wikipedia.org
- Wikidata: Q18579047 wikidata.org