Analysis · Baldur's Gate 3

Baldur's Gate 3 turns every lock, lie and sword swing into a dice roll

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

Almost everything comes down to a d20

Baldur's Gate 3 runs on the fifth edition rules of Dungeons & Dragons, and many of its mechanics match the tabletop game exactly. Most of what you try is settled by a roll of a twenty-sided die. Picking a lock rolls the die and compares the result against the lock's difficulty, with your character's skills and abilities added on top. Some rolls come with advantage or disadvantage, meaning two dice are rolled and you keep the better or worse result.

Outside combat the game moves in real time, under a free camera that runs from a top-down isometric view down to an over-the-shoulder third-person view. A spell or potion lets you talk to any animal you meet and to some corpses. Items in the world can be used in more than one way. An explosive barrel, for example, can be sent to your camp stash and brought back out later.

Critics kept coming back to that freedom. The Guardian's Nick Rueben said the game lets players solve problems creatively, and several reviewers compared Larian to a gracious dungeon master who lets the table try almost anything.

Combat rewards planning and punishes bad luck

Fights are turn-based tactics with lots of options, and some can be avoided entirely. Eurogamer's Ruth Cassidy praised how the game pushes you to think about positioning and to prepare before a fight. Destructoid's Eric Van Allen said combat "ranges from interesting to overwhelming", and that range covers the split among critics.

  • Polygon's Maddy Myers found some systems unintuitive. Coating a weapon in poison, for example, works by using the poison like a health potion instead of through the "dip weapon" function.
  • Polygon's Gita Jackson saved before every encounter, because unlucky rolls could have devastating results she couldn't control.
  • Windows Central's Jennifer Young warned that combat would be "daunting" for people new to D&D. Two critics expected the complexity to divide players, and some reviewers found fights tedious.

Resources add a layer of planning. Hit points and spell slots only come back when you rest. A short rest restores half your maximum hit points, and you get two before a long rest, which sends the party back to camp and refills everything.

Three acts, 288 quests and a cast that can die

The game is split into three acts, each tied to a large area you can explore. Its 288 quests leave a lot of room in how you finish them. Some rule each other out, and some run across several arcs. Almost any character can die, including ones central to the plot, and Windows Central's Young said this gives decisions real weight. The downside, according to PCMag's reviewers, is that some choices can cut off plot lines without you meaning to. Cassidy also felt the main story's urgency rang false.

You start by picking a class, species and backstory. Levels top out at 12, below the tabletop limit of 20, and feats and multiclassing let you shape a build along the way. A camp character named Withers lets you rebuild your character if a build isn't working.

The companions drew the warmest praise. Critics singled out Shadowheart, a healer who serves a goddess of darkness and loss, Karlach, a traumatized barbarian set on finding joy, and Jackson highlighted how the vampire spawn Astarion embraces his freedom. Reviewers were split on the romances: Cassidy said they start too fast, while PCMag praised them for developing naturally and being "unabashedly sexual".

Act three is where the polish slips

Production values got wide praise, especially the cutscenes, the performance capture and a fully voiced cast. The weak spot comes late. Digital Foundry's Alex Battaglia first called the PC version's technical polish impressive, then went back after players pointed him to the ending and found big performance drops in the third act, caused by how dense the city is.

Digital Spy's Jess Lee said "cracks began to show" in act three, citing two companions who ended a relationship in anger over a decision and then forgot it soon after.

Rebekah Valentine said the game's size hid how much less polished the final act is than the first two. IGN reported bug complaints for months after launch, and the first major patch fixed over 1,000 bugs. Not everyone hit them, though: PC Gamer's Fraser Brown was surprised how few bugs he saw given the game's scope.

Built for replays, co-op and mods

You can play alone or with others in co-op, and quests that rule each other out give you real reasons to play again. Origins like the Dark Urge got their own coverage. Mods are supported but turn off achievements. IGN's Wesley Yin-Poole credited mod support for the player count rising 20% over 2024, long after release. The game is on Windows, macOS, Linux, PlayStation 5 and Xbox Series X and Series S, and reached Steam Deck on September 23, 2025. It is rated Mature 17+ and PEGI 18.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet