Analysis · Baldur's Gate: Enhanced Edition

Baldur's Gate kept almost exactly as it was in 1998, with a fresh coat on top

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

The idea is the original game, left intact

This is a remaster of the 1998 Baldur's Gate and its expansion, Tales of the Sword Coast, and it keeps the original elements of both. The rules are still 2nd Edition Advanced Dungeons & Dragons. Travel between locations, the "paper doll" equipment screen and inventory management work the way they always did.

Everything else is built on that choice. Shacknews called it "a truly enhanced version" of a classic. The real question in the reviews was whether a faithful copy of a 1998 game, with additions, was what players wanted in 2012.

The additions sit beside the old content, not over it

Beamdog's team added content and features without rewriting the core:

  • The Black Pits, a stand-alone arena adventure where a party of six fights tougher and tougher opponents.
  • Four new characters, each with their own dialogue and some with their own adventures. A later patch gave only these four the romance feature from Baldur's Gate II.
  • Five class kits: Dwarven Defender, Shadowdancer, Dragon Disciple, Dark Moon Monk and Sun Soul Monk.
  • Classes, subraces and kits brought over from Baldur's Gate II: Shadows of Amn, plus a higher level cap.
  • A revamped interface, higher resolutions and widescreen, a new renderer, and updated map and journal systems.
  • Cross-platform multiplayer, with matchmaking that was still in beta at launch.

All of it fits the central promise. You get more to do and a cleaner way to read it, but the game underneath hasn't changed.

Two difficulty modes stretch the old rules in both directions

The original rules can be harsh on newcomers, and the remaster answers that from both ends. Story Mode makes the party unable to die, sets every character's strength to 25 and makes them immune to most negative effects. Enemies go down easily.

Legacy of Bhaal is the opposite. It's an enhanced Insane setting, and enemies get more hit points, saving throws, THAC0 and attacks per round. Once you pick it, you can't change the difficulty. Choose it only if you already know these rules well.

Faithful also means dated, and critics said so

IGN gave the game 8.1. It said Baldur's Gate had aged well and that new players would get hours of fun from it. It also warned that the framework is increasingly "antiquated" and that players need to go in knowing that. That's the price of the central idea. The same loyalty that pleased returning fans keeps the old systems in place for everyone else.

Critics were mostly favorable. Metacritic lists 78 out of 100 for the PC version. The critic aggregates behind the critic average put the Nintendo Switch, Xbox One, PlayStation 4 and Microsoft Windows versions at 76/100 each, with a second aggregate at 77/100.

The case against paying for it again

The harshest review came from GameBanshee. It listed many bugs and oversights and said it preferred the original release, which has hundreds of mods and bug-fix packs and cost less. GameSpy also asked whether $20 was a fair price, but it praised the cross-platform support.

This criticism tests the central idea directly. If the point is the original game, then the original with community fixes is a real rival. The Enhanced Edition's answer is its new content, its easier mod support, an auto-updater and changes made from player suggestions.

Baldur's Gate

The iPad and Android versions back him up. They replace the old interface with multi-touch zoom, which makes text larger, and you swipe between screens instead of clicking tabs.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet