Analysis · Banished

Banished is a harsh survival sim that turns into a calm town planner

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

Critics split on whether it's a city builder at all

The sharpest disagreement about Banished is over what kind of game it is. Polygon's Charlie Hall said it felt more like a "survival simulation" than a city builder. Eurogamer's Paul Dean called it a "survival sandbox" and stressed how harsh it is. PC Gamer's Andy Chalk saw the same survival game at the start, then said city management takes over as the population grows.

The scores show the split. They run from 6/10 at Eurogamer to 8.3/10 at IGN, and Metacritic called the reviews "mixed or average," with a 73 from 32 reviews. Critics who wanted constant danger saw the game lose its edge. Critics who liked careful planning tended to score it higher.

The hard opening is the part almost everyone liked

You lead a small, isolated group of outcasts and build a settlement with no money at all. Your citizens are the main resource. You assign them jobs such as building or fishing, and they do the work without further orders. They need food and homes. New people arrive only through births and wandering nomads, and everyone ages and dies.

The threats are harsh weather, fire, depression, starvation and an aging population. IGN's Rowan Kaiser praised the game for creating difficulty through the missing money resource instead of making money the main problem. GameSpot's Daniel Starkey praised the difficulty too, and the way each building's role ties into the others so that every structure matters.

Game Informer's Daniel Tack and Kaiser both compared it to Dwarf Fortress. Tack also named Towns, and said Banished is more accessible than both and better looking.

Where the pressure drains away

Most of the complaints are about the late game. Once the town is big and its supply chains are stable, several critics found little left to push against:

  • PC Gamer said survival stops being the focus as the population grows.
  • The Escapist's Greg Tito said it doesn't take long to see everything, and that apart from earning achievements there's no real end goal.
  • IGN said the game suffers whenever the difficulty drops.
  • GameSpot said it lacks a sense of progression.

So the hardest part of Banished is at the start. If you play builders to watch a big city grow toward a goal, this is the weak point.

A town that doesn't explain itself

The second common complaint is feedback. Hall said the game struggles to show you the results of your actions, and Dean agreed that information was hard to get. In a game where one bad winter can starve a town, not knowing why things went wrong is a real cost. Not every critic agreed, though: Tito praised the interface.

Dean also found the strict grid layout generic and formulaic. On the other side, Hall praised the graphics and animations, and Tack singled out the visuals as an improvement on the older games Banished gets compared to.

Who the split favors

Put the reviews together and the audience is clear. Banished suits players who enjoy keeping a fragile group alive through scarcity, where losing a few workers to cold or hunger changes everything. It suits players less if they want clear numbers explaining every outcome or a long campaign of goals.

The first few winters are the game. What comes after is upkeep.

It has stayed in the conversation, too: Rock, Paper, Shotgun named it among its top ten management games for PC in 2020.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet