Battle Brothers is brutal to learn and hard to put down
Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.
Critics agreed on the flaws and split on what they cost
No critic called Battle Brothers easy to learn. They split on whether that matters. Ian Birnbaum at PC Gamer faulted the tutorial for being of little use and the inventory management for being clumsy. He recommended the game anyway, as a tactics formula he loves bent to fit a wide-open medieval setting.
Matt S. at Digitally Downloaded went further on the Switch version. He called its tutorial "incompetent" and said it would make many potential fans give up. Yet he also said that once it clicks, it's very hard to put down.
So critics didn't really disagree about the combat. They disagreed about the opening stretch and how many players will get through it. The aggregate scores show that spread, running from 70 to 82 out of 100 depending on the aggregator and platform. The critic average, computed from those aggregates, is 7.6 out of 10.
You start with the people nobody else would hire
The setup explains much of the friction. You found a mercenary company in a fantasy world modeled on medieval Germany and take contracts for pay. Money is tight early on, so the recruits you can afford are often drunks, criminals and people with crippled limbs.
Those recruits get hurt. Combat can cripple characters physically and emotionally, and permadeath means a lost brother stays lost. You can also set the game to block save scumming, so you can't undo a bad fight by reloading. Later in a campaign, major crises arrive as larger threats. You can adjust the difficulty, including the first crisis.
That mix is what the positive reviews responded to. Bob Richardson at RPGFan said the game "demands your time" and repays it with something thrilling and earthy. Joel A. DeWitte at Nintendo World Report called the difficulty punishing but still wanted to return to that world again and again. PCGamesN put it on its list of the best turn-based strategy games for PC.
The console versions took the harder hits
The sharpest complaints were about the console ports. Jon Jansen at RPGamer praised the combat system but said the user interface was poorly designed for consoles. The Switch version got the "incompetent" tutorial verdict. The PC reviews raised interface problems too, especially with inventory, but treated them as the price of entry rather than a reason to quit.
In practice, this is a game of rosters, gear and contracts, which means a lot of menus. If you can choose, the Windows version drew fewer control complaints. On Xbox, PlayStation or Switch, expect to fight the interface as well as the enemy.
Who will stick with it, and who won't
Taken together, the reviews describe a clear kind of player. Battle Brothers suits people who enjoy losing well. They like a squad of fragile, flawed characters, accept that some will die for good, and want long campaigns where survival is earned. You'll need to learn its systems largely on your own, because the game does a poor job of teaching them.
It's a harder sell if you want a gentle ramp or step-by-step guidance. Digitally Downloaded said outright that the onboarding would cost the game players, and that's the real risk. The combat isn't the problem. The problem is getting far enough to enjoy it.
If you'd rather look things up and lose a few campaigns than be walked through a tutorial, the critics' praise applies to you. If not, their warnings do.
Sources
- Wikipedia: Battle Brothers en.wikipedia.org
- Wikidata: Q29900399 wikidata.org