Battlefield 1 trades modern rifles for trench clubs, horses and zeppelins
Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.
Bolt-action rifles and shovels instead of laser sights
Battlefield 1 is a team shooter set in the First World War, and its arsenal shows it. The game hands players bolt-action rifles, submachine guns, automatic and semi-automatic rifles, flamethrowers, artillery and poison gas. A bolt-action rifle rewards a careful single shot, so the period weapons push fights toward a slower, more deliberate rhythm than a modern setting would.
DICE also reworked melee. Sabres, trench clubs and shovels sit in three weight classes: heavy, medium and light. Close-quarters fighting is built in as a real option, not just a fallback for an empty magazine.
Then there are the vehicles. The list runs from light and heavy tanks, landships and armored cars to torpedo boats, biplanes and triplanes, armored trains, dreadnoughts and M-class zeppelins. Players can also ride horses into battle. Destructible environments return from earlier games in the series and are more dynamic this time, so cover that stands early in a round is not guaranteed to stand later.
Squads matter more than aim
Multiplayer supports up to 64 players, and the game is built around the squad. A new system lets a group join and leave servers together. The game's world designer, Daniel Berlin, said that playing without a squad makes the game much harder. Anyone who usually plays shooters alone should take that seriously.
At launch the game had nine maps and six modes:
- Conquest, Domination, Rush and Team Deathmatch, familiar from earlier entries
- Operations, a new mode that critics singled out for praise
- War Pigeons, where teams secure war pigeons and use them to call in artillery strikes
The maps cover the Middle East, the Western Front, Gallipoli and the Alps. Later expansions added the Eastern Front, the Russian Civil War and naval battles in the North Sea. That spread of fronts, plus the modes added on top, gives the multiplayer a long tail beyond the launch content.
A campaign built as an anthology, and a short one
The single-player campaign is not one long story. It is a collection of separate war stories, each with its own characters. Berlin said the levels are larger and more open than in earlier Battlefield campaigns, with more paths through each mission and more ways to approach a fight.
The prologue tries something different. When the player dies, there is no checkpoint reload. Control passes to another soldier in a different role, from tank gunner to rifleman, and the battle goes on without the one just lost. It is a simple idea that suits the war it depicts.
Critics liked what was there. International Business Times praised the story and level design but called the campaign too short. PC World pointed out a bigger gap: all six campaigns follow the Allied Powers, and the Central Powers' side of the war never appears. For a game praised for taking on a war that popular culture often skips, telling only one side is a real limit.
Why the setting was the big story
Critics praised the First World War setting as fresh and gave DICE credit for the risk of building a big shooter around it. They also praised the multiplayer's solid mechanics, its maps and its soundtrack. Metacritic lists the game's reviews as "generally favorable". Aggregate scores came in at 89/100 on PlayStation 4, 88/100 on personal computer and 87/100 on Xbox One.
The setting caused debate before the game came out. Writing for Wired, Julie Muncy worried that a game could not reflect the war's complexity. Zam's Robert Rath argued that the war had faded from popular culture and that the game might revive interest in it. In The Guardian, Alex Hern turned the question around:
"Asking whether the First World War is an appropriate topic for a first-person shooter may reveal a more pressing question: why do we think any war is?"
That debate is worth knowing about before buying. The game is rated Mature 17+, and it treats poison gas and flamethrowers as everyday tools. It frames the war as a setting for team play first, with the short campaign doing most of the work of giving it weight.
Sources
- Wikipedia: Battlefield 1 en.wikipedia.org
- Wikidata: Q24031560 wikidata.org