Analysis · Battlefield 4

Battlefield 4 is a squad sandbox that critics loved once its servers held up

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

One idea: a sandbox where the team decides

Battlefield 4 is built on one promise: put a lot of players on a large map, give them vehicles and options, and let each squad choose how to win. Joystiq's David Hinkle said the game drops players into a sandbox and "unhooks all tethers". IGN's Mitch Dyer called it "a greatest hits album" of DICE's multiplayer history.

That idea is the test for every other part of the game. Where the game hands control to a team, critics praised it. Where it narrows to one soldier on a scripted path, or where the servers couldn't carry the load, the praise dropped off.

The multiplayer modes are where the idea pays off

Most of the praise went to the modes that give teams room to plan. GameSpot's Chris Watters singled out Obliteration Mode and the multiplayer in general. Commander Mode and the wide range of maps were also called good additions, and Machinima's Lawrence Sonntag praised Levolution along with the multiplayer.

GameZone's Lance Liebl put the idea in plain terms:

"Your success in Battlefield is up to you and how well you work as a team."

Liebl called it one of the most rewarding games he'd played and said the multiplayer made up for its crashes and a Battlelog service that needed work. That trade, a lot of reward with a lot of rough edges, comes up again and again in the reviews.

Small tools that push players to work together

The systems under the modes back up the squad idea. Most of them reward paying attention to your team rather than going it alone:

  • Spotting marks an enemy soldier or vehicle on the mini-map and above their head for the whole team.
  • Color coding sets allies in blue, squadmates in green and enemies in orange, and players with tritanomaly, deuteranomaly or protanomaly can switch to settings made for them.
  • Weapons take attachments and skins, and most can switch between automatic, semi-automatic and burst fire to suit the fight.
  • Heavier bullet drop changes how medium and long-range fights play out.
  • Players can counter melee attacks from the front, fire a sidearm while swimming and dive underwater to hide.

The heads-up display stays small, with two compact boxes in the lower corners and a kill feed at top right, so the map gets most of the screen.

The campaign is where the idea thins out

A scripted story is the opposite of a sandbox, and critics didn't agree on it. Watters at GameSpot was unimpressed with the campaign. Hinkle at Joystiq praised it, but said the multiplayer held no surprises. For the first time in the series, spotting also works in single-player, which carries one squad tool into the story.

PC Gamer's Evan Lahti noted how closely the game resembles Battlefield 3, which came out two years earlier. He still called it "a visually and sonically satisfying, reliably intense FPS". That's fair praise, though it describes polish more than anything new.

A launch that broke the sandbox for a while

A multiplayer sandbox only works if players can get into a match and stay there. At launch, several reviewers reported game-breaking multiplayer bugs on PC, PlayStation 4 and Xbox One, including server crashes and lag. Polygon first scored it 7.5, then cut that to 4, saying the game "was still barely playable for many players".

DICE admitted the problems and said it would put expansions and future projects on hold until they were fixed. Even so, the second expansion came out while many of the recurring problems were still there.

Critic aggregates range from 76 to 85 out of 100 across platforms. The critic average, calculated from those critic numbers, is 8.0 out of 10. That score reflects the multiplayer critics liked. The launch problems explain why one outlet scored it far lower.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet