BattleTech split critics on how good it is, never on whether it's good
Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.
Every critic liked it, and the argument was only over how much
The published scores for BattleTech run from 7/10 to 81/100. No critic panned it. The reception at launch was generally positive, and the argument was only about how high to place it.
The spread is easy to see in the numbers:
- A 7/10 review appeared on April 27, 2018, just after the April 24 release.
- One aggregate of 17 reviews of the Windows version landed at 81/100. Another aggregate, also of 17 reviews, came in at 76/100.
- By March 5, 2020, one pool of 63 reviews averaged 80/100 by one count and 72% by another. The same reviews produce noticeably different results depending on how they're averaged.
The critic average of 7.9 out of 10 comes from those critic numbers by a published formula. It isn't a separate verdict. The written reception doesn't go much beyond "generally positive", so it doesn't explain the gap. The design does, and it shows who will rate the game near the top of that range and who will rate it near the bottom.
Most of the game happens before the shooting starts
You play a mercenary commander leading a lance of four giant humanoid combat vehicles. Fights are turn-based. Much of the work happens in the hangar, though.
For each mech you pick the chassis, then the weapons and armor mounted on it, then smaller parts. Actuators and gyros change how tightly a mech can turn, so a choice made in a menu shows up on the battlefield. Pilots, called mechwarriors, get talents from a skill tree, which adds a second layer of builds on top of the hardware.
That much detail is the reason the scores split. A player who enjoys trading armor for firepower, or saving a turn by fixing a slow gyro, gets a lot out of all this. A player who wants to get to the fighting will hit the same menus and see them as the thing standing in the way.
Inspired by the board game, but not a copy of it
BattleTech carries the name of a tabletop wargame, and the developers were clear about how closely it follows that game. In their words, it keeps the board game's spirit but doesn't use its rules.
Tabletop veterans should expect a familiar setting and the same feel of commanding a lance, not a digital copy of the rulebook.
That matters most to readers who came for a faithful conversion. Players new to the license won't notice it. To them it's simply a tactics game with unusually deep loadouts.
Built by a team that kept adding to it
Harebrained Schemes developed the game and Paradox Interactive published it. The studio put aside US$1 million of its own and went to Kickstarter for extra features: a single-player campaign, an expansion of that campaign and a player-versus-player multiplayer mode.
That's more than many tactics games offer. You get a full campaign for solo play and head-to-head matches against other people. It launched on Windows and macOS on April 24, 2018. Linux players waited until November 27, 2018.
The studio's earlier Shadowrun Returns and Shadowrun: Hong Kong were also turn-based games built around a party you manage closely. If you liked how those played, BattleTech is a heavier, more mechanical version of the same idea.
Sources
- Wikipedia: BattleTech (video game) en.wikipedia.org
- Wikidata: Q21043311 wikidata.org