Analysis · Bayonetta 2

Bayonetta 2 split critics on its extras but never on its combat

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

The real argument was about Tag Climax

Critics disagreed most about Tag Climax, the new online co-op mode. GameSpot's Mark Walton and Eurogamer's Martin Robinson both liked it. Robinson's reason was that it makes players learn the combo scoring system properly. IGN's Jose Otero thought the fun only lasted in short bursts. Polygon's Arthur Gies said the mode pulls in two directions, because it asks partners to work together and then judges them on a competitive score.

That's a narrow fight. Nobody in the record argues about the main game. It holds a 91/100 aggregate on Metacritic from 80 reviews. Famitsu's four reviewers gave it 38 out of 40, and Edge, GameSpot and Destructoid each gave it a perfect 10. The critic average of 9.2 is calculated from those critic scores.

The Tag Climax split is still useful, though. It shows where the game's appeal starts and stops.

The grading system decides who sticks around

Every fight is graded. The top grade, Pure Platinum, goes to players who chain long combos, finish quickly and take no damage. Everything in the game feeds that grade:

  • Witch Time: dodge an attack at the last second and nearby enemies slow down, which opens them up for a counterattack.
  • Torture Attacks: finishers that trap a single enemy in an infernal device and give a bonus.
  • Umbran Climax: new to this game. With a full magic gauge, it briefly powers up your attacks, extends their range and restores health.

This is why the critics split over Tag Climax. If you like the grades, a mode built around scoring gives you more of what you already enjoy. If you just want to see the next set piece, both Otero's short bursts and Gies's mixed signals make sense. Edge said the game can be finished in ten hours but played "forever". That only holds if you want to replay fights for better grades.

The touch controls aren't really for beginners

The game has an optional touchscreen control scheme meant to make it easier for newcomers. Otero and Robinson both criticized it as very limited next to the standard controls. Nobody in the record defends it.

So a newcomer shouldn't count on it as a way in. The accessibility Edge praised, which it described as a balance between "accessibility and depth", comes from the regular controls and the way the systems build on each other. Expect to learn the dodge timing yourself, because the touch option won't handle it for you.

An iterative sequel, and most critics didn't mind

Reviewers agreed the combat is mostly the same as the 2009 original. Robinson called that the game's biggest disappointment, then added that it's less of a problem "when it's iterating on genius".

The improvements critics pointed to are in the structure:

  • Edge said the pacing is tighter and that the sudden mid-cutscene quick-time events that failed you instantly are gone.
  • Otero said its art direction and pacing make the first game look poor by comparison.
  • GameTrailers praised its variety and how it throws players into chaos and lets them fight their way out.

Weapon customization is broader too. You can equip weapons on Bayonetta's hands and feet, including her signature guns, a bow and swords. If you finished the first game hoping for more of the same with fewer rough edges, critics say that's exactly what this is.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet