Below Zero keeps Subnautica's ocean and slips when it walks onto the ice
Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.
A spin-off that stays close to home
Subnautica: Below Zero is a spin-off of Subnautica, developed and published by Unknown Worlds Entertainment. It first came out on January 30, 2019, and released worldwide on May 14, 2021. Instead of moving to a new world, it goes back to the ocean planet 4546B. That choice sets expectations: it's the same underwater survival game, moved to a colder part of a world the series had already built.
Critics mostly approved. Metacritic sums up the reception as "generally favorable," and the critic average, which is calculated from critic aggregates, is 8.1 out of 10. Game Informer's Andrew Reiner was the most enthusiastic. He called it "what every sequel should be" because it adds to the core formula without replacing it.
The loop that carried over almost untouched
The core of the game is unchanged. You gather minerals, plants and fish, then craft tools, build bases and submersibles, and go deeper as your gear improves. You get blueprints by opening databoxes or by scanning fragments of an item. Conditions get harsher the farther you go, so upgrades set the pace: cold-resistant suits, bigger oxygen tanks and vehicles that can handle deeper water.
Oxygen, hunger and thirst all return. So do wrecks and structures that hold blueprints and recorded conversations, which reveal the lore a little at a time. According to IGN's Leana Hafer, the new vehicles, new gadgets and broad improvements to performance and quality of life round out the game. PC Gamer's Rick Lane said environment design is where it improves most clearly on Subnautica.
A voiced lead divided the critics
The first big change is the main character. You play Robin Ayou, a xenologist who comes to 4546B looking for answers about her sister Sam's mysterious death. The first game's protagonist was silent. Robin talks.
Critics disagreed about that change:
- Rick Lane called the characters "dull" and the story less engaging. He argued that having things explained to you takes away the mystery of finding them yourself.
- PJ O'Reilly of Nintendo Life preferred the original's total isolation but said the story stays engaging for its full length.
- Jordan Devore of Destructoid liked the banter between the two leads and found the voice acting good enough that every recording was worth hearing in full.
The new land sections are the weak spot
The second change is land. Below Zero has much larger and more dangerous areas above water than the first game did, plus a new body heat gauge. On land it drains the way oxygen does underwater. You restore it by getting back in the water, finding shelter, eating certain items or standing near a heat source. Blinding snowstorms add another hazard.
This is the one area where critics broadly agreed it fell short, and several named the land sections as the game's low point. O'Reilly said they always wanted to get back in the water. Devore found the land "cooler to look at" than to play, because nothing beats moving freely underwater.
The new ideas work best when they stay in the water.
The five difficulty modes help soften the friction. Survival is the standard mode. Freedom turns off hunger and thirst. Hardcore adds permadeath and deletes your save when you die. Creative turns off every survival meter and unlocks all blueprints. Custom lets you adjust weather, day length and creature aggression. If the survival meters wore on you in the first game, Freedom keeps the exploration and drops most of the upkeep.
Better built, less mysterious
Below Zero polished what it kept. Critics praised the vehicles, tools, environments and technical improvements with little disagreement. Its changes got a more mixed response. The voiced story won over some reviewers and lost others, and the expanded land, its most visible new idea, is the part critics liked least.
In many places it's a better-made game than Subnautica, but it has less of the first game's mystery. It's single-player only, rated Everyone 10+, and available on Windows, macOS, PlayStation 4, PlayStation 5, Xbox One, Xbox Series X and Series S, Nintendo Switch and Android.
Sources
- Wikipedia: Subnautica: Below Zero en.wikipedia.org
- Wikidata: Q56432842 wikidata.org