Analysis · Fire Emblem Fates: Birthright

Birthright is the forgiving half of Fire Emblem Fates, built for newcomers

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

Made for newcomers and fans of Awakening

Fire Emblem Fates is a tactical role-playing game for the Nintendo 3DS, developed by Intelligent Systems and Nintendo SPD and published by Nintendo. It came out in three versions that follow the same characters down different storylines. Birthright is the one aimed at players who are new to the series or who came in through Fire Emblem Awakening. It plays much like Awakening and gives you extra chances to earn gold and experience. Conquest, the other boxed version, rations both.

Critics agreed that this is who Birthright serves. Destructoid's Chris Carter called it the best starting place for series newcomers. Kimberley Keller of Nintendo World Report called it the "perfect way to start" Fates because it sticks to traditional Fire Emblem elements, and Electronic Gaming Monthly's Ray Carsillo also recommended it as a good starting point.

Where it delivers: room to grow and a safety net

Birthright lets you set how much a mistake costs, and that's its biggest strength for a new player. You pick from three difficulties and a separate rule for fallen units:

  • Difficulty: Normal, Hard or Lunatic.
  • Classic Mode: the series' permanent death, where a fallen unit is gone for the rest of the game.
  • Casual Mode: fallen units come back at the end of the battle.
  • Phoenix mode: new to Fates, it revives units on your next turn.

Between battles, the castle feature gives you a base to build. You can level up shops to stock more items, run a farm, and serve food at a restaurant that buffs the characters who eat it (some dishes come with drawbacks). StreetPass lets you visit other players' bases to fight their armies, buy their items and recruit characters, which matters because each version stocks different items. Famitsu found the base felt incomplete at first but called it satisfying in the end.

The presentation drew praise too. IGN's Meghan Sullivan called the story, music and visuals "great". Game Informer's Javy Gwaltney liked the music and graphics, apart from low-res battle models, and he credited the game with real gameplay improvements over Awakening. GameSpot's Alexa Ray Corriea enjoyed the changes to strategy and the character interactions.

Where it falls short: the same kind of fight, map after map

The gentler structure comes at a price. Polygon's Griffin McElroy and Allegra Frank called Birthright a "straightforward march for vengeance" where winning almost always means wiping out a whole platoon or its leader. Corriea noted little variation in the maps, and Sullivan flagged mission repetition. IGN praised Conquest for its mission variety, a point it didn't make about Birthright.

The story split critics. Gwaltney found it "a surprisingly dark tale", while Carter called it "relatively open and shut". Corriea said the dialogue gets overly melodramatic in places. Melanie Zawodniak of Nintendo World Report liked making the player's avatar the protagonist for the "personal stakes" it adds, but called Corrin, that avatar, poorly written.

Critics also listed smaller rough edges:

  • Weak tutorials, according to Gwaltney, which hurts in a version pitched at beginners.
  • A slow online interface, per Sullivan.
  • A character class system Polygon found overly complicated.
  • A translation Eurogamer's Martin Robinson found less "characterful" than Awakening's, plus what he called a "clumsy" removal of the Japanese original's petting mechanic.

The three-version problem hits this audience hardest

Robinson's main complaint was the split release itself. He called it "needlessly convoluted" and warned it might put off fans who came to the series through Awakening, which is the exact crowd Birthright is built for. Famitsu, which reviewed both boxed versions together, noted that playing only one side of the story might leave players unsatisfied.

If you want the harder test, critics pointed the same way. Polygon, Carsillo and GamesRadar's Connor Sheridan all named Conquest the more challenging of the two boxed versions, and Robinson called it the "cooler" one for its challenge and cast. Revelation, the downloadable third version, mixes the two, and Carter called it a good middle ground.

Birthright scored 86/100 on Metacritic from thirty-five critic reviews, against 87/100 for Conquest and 88/100 for Revelation.

Those scores are close enough that the choice is about how much challenge you want, not about quality. Birthright's critic average of 8.5 is computed from critic aggregates. Pick Birthright if you want to learn the series with room to recover from mistakes. Start with Conquest if you already know you like tactics games with strict limits.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet