Analysis · Call of Duty: Black Ops III

Black Ops III wins on sheer volume while critics argue it barely moves forward

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

One critic called it the biggest yet, two called it the status quo

The sharpest split over Black Ops III isn't about whether it's good. It's about whether being bigger counts as progress. IGN gave it 9.2 out of 10 and called it "the biggest Call of Duty game yet," pointing to four-player co-op, new powers and a fuller Zombies mode. GameSpot and Polygon both gave it 7 out of 10 and made almost the opposite point. GameSpot said it does just enough to hold "the Call of Duty status quo." Polygon granted that the amount of content is a fair reason to recommend it, but said Treyarch doesn't "meaningfully move the series forward."

Both camps describe the same game. Neither side claims it is broken or thin. They disagree about what a yearly shooter owes its players. If you want a large, well-stocked version of something you already enjoy, the critics who scored it lower still describe a game you'd like. If you want the series to surprise you, their complaints are the ones to take seriously.

The aggregate scores land in between. The critic average, computed from those critic aggregates, is 7.4 out of 10.

What all that breadth actually covers

The praise for its size has a lot behind it. The campaign is built for four players in co-op, which let Treyarch make wider, more open levels with less corridor shooting. You customize your character's look and spend tokens on weapons and gear as the campaign goes on. A "realistic" difficulty setting ends your run after a single bullet hit.

Beyond the three main modes, the game includes:

  • Nightmares, available once you finish the campaign, retells it with a new story and puts zombies in place of most of the enemies.
  • Dead Ops Arcade, a top-down shooter that follows the version in the first Black Ops.
  • Freerun, a parkour mode about getting through levels quickly with the movement system.

Zombies gets its own XP progression, Gobblegums that give short-lived bonuses, and weapon kits that change both the look and the stats of guns. IGN's case is easy to see: few shooters give you this many separate ways to play.

Multiplayer is built around movement and Specialists

Multiplayer uses a momentum-based movement system. Thruster packs give you boosted jumps, and you can wall run and slide without giving up control of your gun. On top of the Pick 10 class system carried over from Black Ops II, you choose from nine Specialists, each with a unique weapon or ability. A later update added a tenth, Blackjack, who copies other Specialists' abilities and is playable for a limited time after you complete a set of challenges.

The Gunsmith and Paintshop features let you change attachments and paint custom designs on parts of a gun. Players who like tinkering with their loadout have plenty to work with here.

The future setting cost it some goodwill

Story and setting drew the harshest criticism. Stuart Andrews of Trusted Reviews called it a solid entry that would please hardcore fans but not a mainstream crowd-pleaser. His main complaint was that it drops most of the series' conspiracy-thriller feel for augmented super-soldiers. He wrote that it sometimes feels like "Even More Advanced Warfare" more than a third Black Ops game.

If you came to Black Ops for conspiracy-thriller intrigue, the critics who were disappointed are the ones speaking for you.

Players who enjoyed Advanced Warfare's sci-fi will probably see this as a plus.

The version you pick changes the game

The PS3 and Xbox 360 versions came from Beenox and Mercenary Technology. They include multiplayer modes only, with no campaign. IGN's Brian Albert criticized the missing campaign, the weak graphics and the long waits, though he still found those versions fun. On Metacritic, the PlayStation 4 and Xbox One versions rated "generally favorable," while the PC version rated "mixed or average." For the full package with co-op, Nightmares and everything else, you need the PlayStation 4, Xbox One or PC version.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet