Borderlands 3 sharpens the shooting and leaves the jokes up for debate
Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.
The fight over the writing, not the shooting
Critics didn't argue much about how Borderlands 3 plays. GameSpot and PC Gamer both credited it with refinements to movement, the skill system and the series' signature visual style. They argued about the voice.
GameSpot counted the series' "juvenile humor and ludicrous jokes" and its "personable" cast among the hallmarks it kept, and said the story "satisfyingly wraps up" character arcs fans had followed for 10 years. PC Gamer called the game "the best and worst of the series all at once" and was much harsher on the script. It compared the writing unfavorably with Tales from the Borderlands and said it reads like "teenage lunch table improv."
Same jokes, same cast, opposite verdicts. Your reaction to the humor in Borderlands 2 is the best predictor of how this one will go.
That makes the split useful. Critics weren't confused about what the game is. They saw the same thing and wanted different things from it.
What the guns and skill trees add
The loop is unchanged: take missions from characters and bounty boards, kill enemies, collect loot, level up and spend skill points. Most of the loot is procedurally generated weapons, enough for a claimed "over one billion guns", each varying in damage, range, ammo capacity and perks.
The changes are in the details:
- Three action skills per character. Earlier games gave each class one skill on a cooldown. Here, each of the four new characters has three, with one equipped at a time (two for Zane), which opens up many more builds.
- Gun makers matter more. Tediore guns can be thrown when empty, Atlas guns fire tracking bullets that find enemies in cover, and Hyperion guns can carry shields that absorb damage and turn it into healing.
- Radiation replaces slag. Instead of a debuff that set up other elements, radiation damages enemies over time and can spread when an enemy explodes on death.
The cast covers distinct playstyles: Amara the Siren summons ethereal fists, Moze the Gunner rides the mech Iron Bear, Zane the Operative uses gadgets, and FL4K the robot Beastmaster summons creatures.
Where even the fans saw it drag
Both critics flagged the same weakness. GameSpot said the pacing was still broken up by boss fights with little strategy and "bullet sponge" enemies. PC Gamer called enemies "too dumb and erratic and spongy to force tactical play." When the main appeal is shooting, enemies that only absorb damage wear thin.
PC Gamer had more complaints. The new planets add variety after Pandora's "muted deserts", but they often bring back old characters who say hello, crack a few one-liners and fade out. It also called the endgame "shallow" at launch.
The launch had technical trouble too. Some Windows players hit performance problems and console players saw lower frame rates than expected, both of which Gearbox Software said it was investigating.
Who the split points to
GameSpot's verdict is the clearest guide: if you've never been a fan of the series, Borderlands 3 probably doesn't change enough to win you over. It does best at what the series has always done.
That points to three kinds of player:
- Returning fans get the conclusion to long-running character arcs, plus a deeper build system than earlier games had.
- Co-op groups get an option that generates loot for each player, so nobody fights over drops, and another that scales enemies to each player's level. Friends at different levels can play together without one of them carrying the rest.
- Players who like tinkering with builds get three action skills per character and gun makers whose perks change how a weapon plays.
Players who want smart enemy AI, tight writing or a long endgame from day one are the ones critics warned off. The game is rated Mature 17+, and the humor PC Gamer disliked sets the tone throughout.
The critic average of 7.9 is computed from those critic aggregates. It's a fair average, but the split underneath it matters more than the number.
Sources
- Wikipedia: Borderlands 3 en.wikipedia.org
- Wikidata: Q62565771 wikidata.org