Analysis · Brawlhalla

Brawlhalla wins on movement and price, not on tight design

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

The written reviews liked it more than the averages did

Critics didn't really disagree about whether Brawlhalla is fun. They disagreed about how much it adds up to. The individual reviews were warm. Kotaku said it "feels good to play," Nintendo Life called it "easy to recommend" and PCMag said it was something you could "enjoy for free."

The aggregate scores were cooler. In June 2019 the game sat at 68/100 across 11 reviews. By May 2022, a count of 12 reviews put it at 45%.

Push Square's 7 out of 10 falls between those numbers and helps explain the gap. The outlet said the game isn't as tightly designed as Super Smash Bros. It still praised the large roster, the range of modes and a reasonable level of depth. That's the dividing line: Brawlhalla is built to be easy to start, and some critics judged it against the best game in its genre. Its critic average, computed from those critic aggregates, is 6.8.

Movement is where it earns its praise

The goal is the familiar one for this genre. You knock opponents into blastzones, the areas past the edges of the map, or you stop them from getting back to the stage and let them fall. Instead of a percentage, a color ring around each character's icon shows damage. It shifts from white to red to black, and the darker it gets, the farther a hit sends that character.

Kotaku pointed to movement as the game's best idea. Each character gets three jumps, a directional air dodge and fast-falling. Players can also cling to stage walls and climb them almost without limit. That extra mobility moves a lot of the fighting off the stage, into the space where a recovery can turn into a comeback or a knockout. Kotaku said these choices make for fresh strategies, and this is the clearest reason to pick Brawlhalla over another platform fighter.

Easy to start, with depth underneath

The controls are simple. There are buttons for attacking, special moves, picking up or throwing weapons and dodging, and every special move takes one button. New players can start landing hits right away. Advanced techniques like the gravity-cancel, which lets a player use a grounded move in midair, give experienced players something to work toward.

Weapons do most of the work of telling characters apart. Each of the 70 Legends uses two of 15 weapons. A weapon drop always looks like a sword but turns into whichever weapon fits the Legend who grabs it. Blasters, bows, spears and rocket lances work best at range. Katars and gauntlets work best up close. Gadgets also fall from the sky during matches, and players can switch them off in ranked modes. That lets casual matches stay chaotic while competitive ones stay cleaner.

Who the split points to

The praise focused on access and variety, and the doubts focused on precision. That tells you who the game suits. It has a mode for nearly any group:

  • Ranked 1v1, plus ranked 2v2 with a partner in a standard queue or a seasonal rotating one
  • Free-For-All, where four players compete for points
  • 1v1 Strikeout, where each player picks three Legends with one stock each
  • Custom games for up to eight players, online or local
  • Experimental 1v1 and a featured mode that changes every week

Full cross-play means friends on different platforms can play together, and the free-to-play model means nobody has to pay to join. Clans are the exception, since they're only available on PC. The game is rated Everyone 10+.

Players who want a fighter with the precise design Push Square found in Super Smash Bros. are the ones most likely to agree with the lower aggregate. If you want a fast, free brawler with lots of characters, the warm written reviews are a better guide.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet