Breath of the Wild hands you every tool in the first hour, then lets go
Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.
Any surface is a path and any object is a tool
Most of the game is about getting somewhere and deciding what to do once you're there. Link can run, swim, climb almost any surface and glide off high points with a paraglider. A stamina meter limits all of it, so a long climb or a long glide is a small bet you make again and again.
A "chemistry engine" sets the physical properties of most objects and controls how they react to Link and to each other. In a thunderstorm, metal gear draws lightning. That's a danger if you're carrying it and a weapon if you throw it at an enemy. Wooden weapons can light fires. A wooden shield can catch arrows. Some shields work as makeshift snowboards. You can also beat an enemy camp without swinging a sword, for example by rolling a boulder down a cliff into it.
The Sheikah Slate, a magic stone tablet, adds a small set of powers:
- remote bombs
- a magnet that moves metal objects
- ice blocks raised from water
- freezing certain objects in time
It also takes photos of creatures, materials and enemies. Those photos fill the Hyrule Compendium, which then helps you find valuable items.
Weapons break, so you keep improvising
For the first time in the series, weapons and shields wear down and eventually shatter. The game wants you to keep picking up whatever is nearby, and much of the reviewers' praise for experimentation comes from that pressure. Food works the same way. You hunt, forage and collect parts from defeated enemies, then cook them into meals and elixirs that restore health and stamina or protect you from heat and cold for a while.
This was also the most divisive part of the design. James Stephanie Sterling gave the game a 7/10. Sterling criticized weapon durability, the difficulty and the level design, while still praising the open world and the variety of things to do. If you get attached to your favorite sword, expect friction.
No set route through Hyrule
Areas don't have defined entrances or exits. The game gives you very little instruction, and you can finish the main story, Link's attempt to save Princess Zelda and stop Calamity Ganon, in whatever order you like. Edge put the appeal plainly: since you get every tool in the opening hour, the answer to any problem is already in your hands.
Critics contrasted it with "Ubisoft-style" maps covered in markers. Here, the marks on your map are a record of what you chose to find.
Jose Otero of IGN called it "a masterclass in open-world design." GameSpot said it was the most impressive game Nintendo had made, both a return to form and a step into new territory. Kyle Orland of Ars Technica wrote that it reinvented the Zelda formula. Digital Trends credited the climb-anywhere, glide-anywhere movement with pushing other developers to rethink vertical design. Chris Plante of The Verge predicted that open-ended problem solving like this would shape a new generation of games.
Quiet cues, rough performance
Reviewers praised how much the world tells you without words. Kotaku even suggested switching off parts of the on-screen display, because the game already shows the same information in context: Link shivers when he's cold, and waypoints appear when you look through the scope. Critics also enjoyed the odd interactions between Link, villagers, pets and enemies, and many of those clips spread widely on social media. A tribute to former Nintendo president Satoru Iwata, who died during development, was praised as well.
The technical side drew real complaints: an unstable frame rate and a resolution of 900p. Later updates fixed some of these problems, but not all of them.
Why it still holds up
Since the world runs on rules rather than scripts, players kept finding new tricks years after release, according to Digital Trends. The awards back up its staying power. It won Game of the Year at both the Game Awards 2017 and the 21st D.I.C.E. Awards, and Metacritic counts it at the top of 18 best-of-the-decade lists, more than any other game of the 2010s. A game you can still learn from after that long is worth the time, even with the breaking swords.
Sources
- Wikipedia: The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild en.wikipedia.org
- Wikidata: Q17185964 wikidata.org