Brothership is built on connection, but its weak link is the space between
Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.
A broken world that you plug back together
Critics read Brothership as a game about connection, and the design follows that idea closely. The world of Concordia has split into islands. Your main task on each one is to find it and reconnect it to Shipshape Island, a central hub that works like a ship, using a giant plug. Each island you connect brings more characters to the hub.
The story carries the same theme. GameSpot's Steve Watts called it a "sweet if simple fable about togetherness and human connection." The Gamer's Eric Switzer found it "surprisingly mature and impactful for a Mario game." Even Giovanni Colantonio of Digital Trends, one of the harsher critics, called it "the most socially relevant a Mario game has ever felt."
The controls follow the theme too. Mario and Luigi each have their own button, both out in the world and in battle, so every action asks you to handle two characters at once.
Combat is where the two-brother idea pays off
Battles use the series' familiar formula. You attack with a jump or a hammer, use items to heal or run away. Pressing a button at the right moment boosts your attacks, dodges enemy hits or sets up a counterattack. The brothers can also join in on each other's basic attacks for extra damage, and as the game goes on, Bros. Attacks open up, mixing new moves with returning ones.
The new layer is Battle Plugs. These are upgrades that give you a bonus in battle, such as easier counterattacks, health recovery or more attack power. You can swap them at the start of a character's turn, but each plug has a limited number of charges that run out and must be recharged. That makes them a resource to manage, not a passive bonus.
This is the part critics agreed on most. Nintendo Life's PJ O'Reilly and Shacknews' Ozzie Mejia both praised the combat, Watts singled out the Plug mechanic, and PCMag's Will Greenwald gave the game an Editor's Choice award, calling it "colorful, charming, mechanically engaging."
Luigi Logic is the idea critics split on
Luigi Logic lets Luigi act on his own. He picks up items, helps solve some puzzles and comes up with new moves for boss fights. On paper, it's the clearest version of the game's theme: Luigi as a partner who thinks for himself, not a shadow who copies Mario.
Critics didn't agree on how well it works. TechRadar's Josephine Watson enjoyed the puzzles. IGN's Logan Plant, who scored the game 5/10, disliked both Luigi's automated movement in the overworld and his role in solving puzzles. When the game takes control away from you to show off the brothers' teamwork, some players will feel left out of that teamwork.
The parts between the islands are the weak link
A game about connection lives or dies on what links its pieces, and this is where critics found the trouble. Switzer criticized the sailing system that moves you between islands. Watts disliked the pacing and felt the game was too ambitious for its own good because of its length. Colantonio criticized the pacing as well and found the humor flat. Plant also pointed to a lack of originality in the locations.
Performance came up again and again. Watson put the problems down to what she called the "Nintendo Switch generational curse," Plant ranked the game's technical performance among the worst on the system, and other reviewers raised the same issue.
The art is the one thing nobody argued about. The Daily Mirror's Aaron Potter called it "the best the RPG series has ever looked."
The overall reception stayed positive. Metacritic counted the reviews as "generally favorable," and four Famitsu critics gave it a combined 34 out of 40. The core of the game holds up. Getting from one good part to the next takes patience.
Sources
- Wikipedia: Mario & Luigi: Brothership en.wikipedia.org
- Wikidata: Q126722673 wikidata.org