Analysis · Call of Duty 4: Modern Warfare

Call of Duty 4 pairs a short, scripted campaign with deep multiplayer

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

The campaign is both the highlight and the complaint

Critics disagreed most about the single-player campaign. The same reviewers who praised it also held it back. GameSpot's Jeff Gerstmann called it brief, but said its quality and the multiplayer still made the game a strong package. IGN praised its scripted sequences and also noted that it stayed linear. Across the reviews, the most common criticism was its short length and fixed path.

That split tells you a lot about the design. The campaign moves between members of the British Special Air Service and the United States Marine Corps. Its missions are built around clear objectives: reach a checkpoint, clear a position, defend a spot, plant explosives. The compass and HUD point you at each goal. It's a guided ride, built from big set pieces, and the praise and the complaints both come from that choice.

Finishing the campaign opens up "Mile High Club," a separate epilogue in which an SAS squad rescues a hostage from a hijacked plane. There are 30 pieces of enemy intel hidden along the way. Collecting them earns optional cheats and visual filters, which gives completionists a reason to replay missions.

Polish, not reinvention

Critics also split on how much the game changed. GamesRadar+ called it finely crafted but said it wasn't a major departure from earlier Call of Duty games. X-Play described the same quality more kindly, saying the game came close to perfecting the shooter formula rather than reinventing it.

The biggest change was the setting. The series left World War II for modern times, and critics broadly praised the move. The arsenal changed with it: flashbangs, night vision and suppressed weapons. The basics stayed familiar. You stand, crouch or go prone, and lower stances tighten your aim. Health regenerates once you get out of enemy fire.

If you want a shooter that rethinks the genre, this isn't it. If you want a familiar formula done with unusual care, critics agreed this is close to the high-water mark.

Multiplayer is why it lasted

Reviewers singled out the multiplayer more often than anything else. GamePro compared its depth and reach to Halo 3. At the 11th Annual Interactive Achievement Awards, the game won Outstanding Achievement in Online Gameplay as well as Overall Game of the Year.

The systems behind that praise are easy to list:

  • Experience and rank. Kills, capturing control points and calling in support all earn experience. Rank opens up new weapons, perks and class options.
  • Custom classes. You pick a primary weapon, a sidearm, attachments, a special grenade and three perks drawn from three groups.
  • Killstreaks. Three kills without dying calls in a UAV scan, five an airstrike and seven an attack helicopter.
  • Prestige. On consoles, hitting the level cap lets you reset your rank for a new insignia, up to ten times.

This is the part of the game for players who will put in the evenings. The short campaign matters much less if you plan to spend most of your time here.

Pick your version carefully

The scores split sharply by platform. Aggregate scores run 94/100 on Xbox 360, 93/100 on PlayStation 3 and 92/100 on PC. The 2009 Wii port, Reflex Edition, sits at 76/100. GameSpot gave it 8.5/10 for keeping the campaign and online play, but noted occasional aiming trouble and weaker visuals. IGN gave it 7.0/10 and said its pointer controls and graphics were less polished than Call of Duty: World at War on the same console.

The game is rated Mature 17+ and PEGI 16, so it isn't one for younger players.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet